Showing posts with label Kalpakkam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kalpakkam. Show all posts

17 September 2013

Volcano near Kalpakkam Nuke Plant? - Public Interest Litigation

In the High Court of Judicature at Madras
(Special Original Jurisdiction)

W.P. No.                       of 2013

M.Vetri Selvan
Advocate
1-P, Pandu klix Plaza,
330/168, Thambu Street,
Chennai - 600001                                                                       .. Petitioner

vs

1.  Union of India
represented by the Secretary to Govt. of India
Department of Atomic Energy
Anushakti Bhavan
Chatrapathi Shivaji Maharaj Marg
Mumbai 400 001

2. Union of India
represented by the Secretary to Govt.
Ministry of Environment and Forests
Paryavaran Bhawan
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road
New Delhi 110 003

3.The Chairman
Atomic Energy Regulatory Board
Niyamak Bhavan
Anushaktinagar
Mumbai  400 094   

4. The Chairman and Managing Director
Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited
Nambhkiya Urja Bhavan
Anushakti Nagar
Mumbai  400 094

5.  The Member Secretary
Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board
Guindy, Chennai  600 032                                                 ...Respondents

AFFIDAVIT

       I, M.Vetri Selvan, S/o S.Muthuraj, aged about  31 years, having office  at 1-P, Pandu klix Plaza, 330/168, Thambu Street, Chennai - 600 001 do hereby on solemn affirmation state as under:

1.                 I am the petitioner herein.  I am conversant with the facts of the case.  I am competent to file this affidavit.
2.                I state that I am an advocate having a standing of more than five years. I am also actively associated with “Poovulagin Nanbargal”, a registered public trust working for the protection of environment and forests. I am initiating this Public Interest Litigation in discharge of my fundamental duties under Article 51-A (g),   (h) and (j) of the Constitution.    Earlier I have filed a public interest litigation  viz.  WP No. 26097 of 2011 questioning the failure of the respondents to implement the Guidelines on Management of Nuclear and Radiological Emergencies with regard to Madras Atomic Power Station, Kalpakkam, Kancheepuram District.
3.                I state that the Madras Atomic Power Station (MAPS) is located at Kalpakkam, about 70 kms from Chennai City.  The power station consists of two units viz.   MAPS-1 and MAPS-2. MAPS-1 and MAPS-2 went critical in 1983 and 1985 respectively.  At Kalpakkam, there are seven nuclear organizations including MAPS viz. Bharatiya Nabhikiya Vidyut Nigam Ltd. (HQ), Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Research, PFBR Project (IGCAR), Nuclear Desalination Demonstration Plant (BARC), Kalpakkam Fuel Reprocessing Plant (BARC) and General Services Organisation.  Presently, the MAPS produces 440 MW of electricity from the two reactors.  It is learnt that the Union of India has plans for an additional 500 MW capacity in MAPS. 
4.                I state that on 26 March 1999 there was Heavy water leaks in MAPS and seven people received a full radiation dose. According to Dr. A. Gopalakrishnan, former Chairman of the Atomic Energy Regulatory Board, in the early 1980s, the discovery of some pieces of zircalloy in a moderator pump in MAPS Unit 1 was traced to the problem of substantial crackingof the reactor inlet manifold and an identical problem surfaced in MAPS-2 also almost during the same period and that the synergy of different kinds of serious safety issues in MAPS 1 and 2 put the station at a higher risk than acceptable anywhere else in the world.  Frontline, a fortnightly in English, (March 16-23, 1999) reported  about Dr. A. Gopalakrishnan’s view about the said heavy water leak in MAPS: 

“Gopalakrishnan said that going by the initial estimates given by MAPS, several tones, possibly 14 tonnes, of heavy water leaked out.  “For this number the declaration of a plant emergency makes sense,” he said.  “You will not declare a plant emergency if just one bucketful of heavy water leaks or about 10 workers are concerned.  A very large amount must have gone into the drain and spread out.  The (tritium) release must have also been sucked into the ventilation system.”  It reports further:  “Tritium is highly radioactive, with a half-life of over 12 years.  Tritium content in heavy water increases with the number of years the reactor operates.  Almost all the tritium continues to be in the heavy water even if the reactor is shut down for a couple of months.  When there is a spillage of heavy water, the tritium affects the plant personnel.”  Dr. A. Gopalakrishnan, on account of the fact that micro-cracks in the coolant tubes would ultimately lead to a fire in the reactor, expressed great concern about the workers also.  The report says: “He demanded that personnel in MAPS be given the data on the release of radiation and be told how much radiation they had ingested.  He said that he was deeply concerned about the use of contract labour for cleaning jobs because they were often overexposed to radiation.”

5.                 I state that even after such caution by the former Chairman of Atomic Energy Regulatory Board, there were two more incidents in 2001 and 2002.  On 30 May 2001, one Mr.S. Sivakumar, a worker, suffered internal contamination after a neoprene glove was punctured.  On 7 July 2002, one Selvakumar, a worker, burnt his left hand after he picked up a radioactive substance.  Moreover, as reported in Tehelka (2010), the General Secretary of the BARC Facilities Employees Association in his letter dated 24 January 2003 addressed to the Director of Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC) recounted in detail a significant nuclear accident that took place on 21 January 2003 at MAPS where one worker named Raju and 5 others including a woman were exposed to high levels of radiation.  After about eight months of the accident, Mr.B. Bhattacharjee, then Director of BARC, termed it “the worst accident in India’s nuclear history.”
6.                  I state that an estimated 30,000 workers live in the five villages that fall within the 5 km radius from MAPS.  There is a DAE township which accommodates thousands of permanent workers and their families.  Within the 16 km to 20 km radius from MAPS, there are about 60 villages where more than 1 lakh people live.  Since plant operations begain in the early 1980s, incidents of cancer and auto-immune thyroid diseases in the surrounding villages have increased.  A contract labour’s three year old child has been diagnosed with retinoblastoma or cancer of eyes.  Radiation from the nuclear plant is responsible for the child’s condition, doctors say.  Life of thousands of innocent people living in the villages which are within the radius of about 16 km to 20 km from MAPS is at stake. 
7.                     I state that the world was shocked to view the unprecedented nuclear disaster occurred on March 11, 2011 at Fukushima Dai-ichi Plant, Japan. An estimated 11,000 people were evacuated in a 20-km radius around the nuclear plant immediately after the accident.  United Kingdom, France and some other countries told their nationals to consider leaving Tokyo with a view to escaping from radioactive contamination.  Large amounts of radioactive isotopes were also released into the Pacific Ocean.  As of July 2011, the Japanese government found it impossible  to control the spread of radioactive material into the nation’s food and  radioactive material was being  detected in a range of produce, including spinach, tea leaves, milk, fish and beef, up to 200 miles from the nuclear plant. Inside the 12-mile evacuation zone around the plant, all farming was abandoned. As of August 2011, the crippled Fukushima nuclear plant was found still leaking low levels of radiation and areas surrounding it was found   uninhabitable for decades due to high radiation. According to experts, it would be at least 20 years before the residents could safely return to this area where high level radiation still prevails. This nuclear disaster made the respondent-Nuclear Power Corporation of India (NPCIL) on 15th March, 2011 constitutes four Task forces to review consequences of Fukushima similar situations in Indian Nuclear Power Plants under operation. One among the Task Force comprising an Executive Director, Technical Services Superintend, MAPS, and three Additional Chief Engineers has been constituted for “Safety Evaluation of Indian Nuclear Power plants PHWRs at Madras Atomic Power Station (MAPS)”. This Task Force has submitted an Interim Report by the end of March 2011. The Task force has made 12 Short term recommendations and 8 long term recommendations to be carried out in the MAPS.  The NPCIL-Task force report concludes stating: “The recommendation of the task forces have been reviewed and discussed. Action plans for the near term and long term are being worked out. As brought out earlier, this report is an interim one. As the event at Fukushima further unfolds and additional information is available, the recommendations will be revisited and changes, if any, will be incorporated.” The report also fixes timeline for completion of the recommendations. The maximum period given for fulfilling the recommendations is 14 months. It appears that no final report has so far been submitted by the Task Force to the respondent-Union of India with regard to the completion of recommendations made by the respondent NPCIL-Task force report.
8.                I state that respondent-Atomic Energy Regulatory Board (AERB) constituted a committee on March 19, 2011 to review the safety of Indian Nuclear Power Plants against external events of natural origin, in the light of the Fukushima accident. The committee has submitted its report on 31st August, 2011. At paras 4.17 and 4.18, under the heading “Spent fuel storage facilities”, the report reads:
“4.17.   For the spent fuel storage pools at our NPPs it is seen that the stored fuel remains submerged in water for a period ranging from 9 to 16 days in the older plants viz. TAPS-1&2, RAPS-1&2 and MAPS-1&2, and for over one month in other plants, without any cooling or addition of water. Nevertheless an external water hookup provision for changing water in the pools for all the operating plants should be implemented. This make up capability should remain unaffected by the external events and SBO. Provision for monitoring the level and temperature of pool water and radiation fields inside the spent fuel storage buildings under SBO should also be made. 4.18. Detailed site specific safety assessment of spent fuel storage bays should be carried out with respect to structural integrity and leak-tightness of pools, loss of pool water from sloshing and, stability of fuel racks and mechanical handling equipment in case of extreme earthquake event”.

Further the committee has also recommended as follows:
“4.24. The practice of storing spent radioactive ion exchange resins in underground tanks should be discontinued as in case of earthquake or severe flooding this can cause spread of radioactive contamination. The resins presently stored in such tanks at TAPS and MAPS should be appropriately treated and disposed off. 4.25. Functional integrity of radioactive liquid effluent storage tanks and surrounding dykes at NPPs should be assessed under beyond design basis external events and corrective measures implemented as necessary”.
Annexure 5 to the AERB committee’s report under the caption “8. Working group to review safety of near surface radioactive waste disposal facilities and liquid waste storage tanks at NPP sites against external events” reads:
“At TAPS (1&2) and MAPS (1&2), spent resins generated from the reactors are stored in underground tanks. The ingress of water into the storage tanks or failure of storage tanks has the potential of spreading contamination in the surrounding environment. At present the radionuclide monitoring data in bore wells around the spent resin storage facility shows safety of storage as activity levels are below the detection limit (BDL). This establishes the integrity of storage tanks. The practice of storing spent resin in water at underground tank needs further investigation. However, early immobilization of these resins and discontinuation of practice of storage of spent resins in underground tank is recommended.”

9.       I state that the respondent-AERB has vide its communication dated 31 May 2013 addressed to me under the Right to Information Act made it clear that all the recommendations of NPCIL Committee/Task Force and the high level AERB Committee constituted  post-Fukushima  disaster have not so far been implemented with regard to MAPS.  The AERB has also admitted in the said communication : "AERB is aware of the information in the Smithsonian's Global Volcanism Program official website about the reported volcano (in 1757) located at about 100-110 km from Kalpakkam with status uncertain.  ...  ... However, GSI and others have recommended for further data/analysis in view of an inferred high density material intrusion of remnant magnetisation based on magnetic and gravity anomalies around the said location.   Based on the above feedback, AERB has asked the utilities at Kalpakkam to undertake detailed study through expert agencies.  The work in this regard is in progress."    
10.               I state that the schedule to 2006 notification viz. Notification dated 14th September 2006 issued under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 contains an entry "Nuclear power projects and processing of nuclear fuel".   "Spent fuel", stored in MAPS, satisfies the expression "Processing of nuclear fuel". Rule 2 (t) of the Atomic Energy (Radiation Protection) Rules, 2004 defines nuclear fuel cycle to mean among other things "radioactive waste management".   "Unstoppable and Unstorable" nuclear waste would always have environmental impact demanding fresh Environment Impact Assessment and further demanding fresh Environmental Clearance.  Moreover, any environmental clearance granted under the said notification for nuclear power project would be valid only for a period of five years.  No environmental clearance has so far been obtained for storing spent fuel in MAPS.  The AERB Committee has vide its recommendations with regard to storage of spent fuel in MAPS emphasises that the practice of storing spent radioactive ion exchange resins in underground tanks should be discontinued as in case of earthquake or severe flooding this can cause spread of radiocative contamination. Fresh environment impact assessment would be the need of the hour viewed in the light of the stand of AERB that a detailed study with regard to the presence of volcano about 100 - 110 kilometers near MAPS is in progress. Hence this Writ Petition in public interest on the following ground : 

GROUND
          It is submitted that the recommendations of the NPCIL Committee / Task Force and the AERB Committee constituted post - Fukushima disaster have not so far been fully implemented by the AERB and other respondents.   It is admitted by AERB vide its communication dated 31.05.2013 addressed to the petitioner under the Right to Information Act that detailed study into the presence of volcano near Madras Atomic Power Station, Kalpakkam is in progress.   It is also admitted by the AERB that no Environmental Clearance with regard to storage of spent fuel in MAPS has ever been obtained by the respondent - authorities.   Obviously, unstoppable and unstorable nuclear waste would always have environmental impact.   It is saddening to note that without any Environmental Clearance, Madras Atomic Power Station (Units.I & II) is functioning for more than three decades.   The Supreme Court has in G.Sundarrajan Vs Union of India and others : (2013) 4 MLJ 46 (SC) held : "No plant specifically the one dealing with radioactive materials can be allowed to function or commission even if it has been cleared by AEC, AERB, NPCIL etc. unless it strictly conforms to the standards set by the statutory authorities like MoEF, TNPCB etc. and follow the environmental laws".  The failure of the respondents to make a fresh Environment Impact Assessment and obtain a fresh Environmental Clearance with regard to Madras Atomic Power Station, Kalpakkam Units I & II would be violative of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution.

11.     I state that I have no personal interest in the case.  I have earlier filed a couple of public interest litigations viz. WP No. 14866/2009 (M.Vetri Selvan Vs. Union of India and others: 2010 (4) CTC 465) and W.P. No. 19192 of 2010 decided on 16.11.2010.  I have also filed WP No. 8034/ 2011 decided on 01.04.2011 (Manivannan Vs. Union of India and others: 2011 (3) CTC 785).  I undertake to pay the costs, if any, if this PIL is found to be intended for personal gain or oblique motive.  I have filed this petition from my own funds.  To my knowledge, no PIL arising on the issue raised in this petition has been filed anywhere.  This public interest litigation is maintainable in law. The contents of this paragraph are in compliance with the Rules to regulate the Public Interest Litigations filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

Solemnly affirmed at Chennai                                      Before me
this the 10th day of September 2013
and signed his name in my
presence.                        
:                                                             Advocate, Chennai



MEMORANDUM OF WRIT PETITION
UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION
In the High Court of Judicature at Madras
(Special Original Jurisdiction)

W.P. No.                       of 2013

M.Vetri Selvan
Advocate
1-P, Pandu klix Plaza,
330/168, Thambu Street,
Chennai - 600001                                                                       .. Petitioner

vs

1.  Union of India
represented by the Secretary to Govt. of India
Department of Atomic Energy
Anushakti Bhavan
Chatrapathi Shivaji Maharaj Marg
Mumbai 400 001

2. Union of India
represented by the Secretary to Govt.
Ministry of Environment and Forests
Paryavaran Bhawan
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road
New Delhi 110 003

3.The Chairman
Atomic Energy Regulatory Board
Niyamak Bhavan
Anushaktinagar
Mumbai  400 094   

4. The Chairman and Managing Director
Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited
Nambhkiya Urja Bhavan
Anushakti Nagar
Mumbai  400 094

5.  The Member Secretary
Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board
Guindy, Chennai  600 032                                                 ...Respondents

WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION

1..      The address for service of the petitioner is that of his counsel M.Radhakrishnan, Advocate, 134, Thambu Chetty Street, Chennai. 600 001.

2..      The address for service on the respondent is as stated above.

3..      For the reasons stated in the accompanying affidavit, it is prayed that the Hon’ble Court be pleased to issue a WRIT OF MANDAMUS forbearing the respondents from running the Madras Atomic Power Station (Units I & II), Kalpakkam, Kanchipuram District without first obtaining Environmental Clearance with regard to MAPS in accordance with law,  and thus render justice.

Dated at Chennai, this the 10th day of September 2013

Counsel for the petitioner.



MEMORANDUM OF MISCELLANEOUS PETITION
UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION
In the High Court of Judicature at Madras
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
M.P. No.          of 2013
in
W.P. No.                       of 2013

M.Vetri Selvan
Advocate
1-P, Pandu klix Plaza,
330/168, Thambu Street,
Chennai - 600001                                                                       .. Petitioner

vs

1.  Union of India
represented by the Secretary to Govt. of India
Department of Atomic Energy
Anushakti Bhavan
Chatrapathi Shivaji Maharaj Marg
Mumbai 400 001

2. Union of India
represented by the Secretary to Govt.
Ministry of Environment and Forests
Paryavaran Bhawan
CGO Complex, Lodhi Road
New Delhi 110 003

3.The Chairman
Atomic Energy Regulatory Board
Niyamak Bhavan
Anushaktinagar
Mumbai  400 094   

4. The Chairman and Managing Director
Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited
Nambhkiya Urja Bhavan
Anushakti Nagar
Mumbai  400 094

5.  The Member Secretary
Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board
Guindy, Chennai  600 032                                                 ...Respondents




PETITION FOR INTERIM DIRECTION
UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION

          For the reasons stated in the affidavit filed in support of the Writ Petition it is prayed that the Hon'ble Court be pleased to grant an interim direction directing the respondents to take immediate steps for disposal of radioactive waste stored in and around Madras Atomic Power Station (Units I & II), Kalpakkam, Kanchipuram District as mandated by the Atomic Energy Regulatory Board vide its report dated 31 August 2011 pending disposal of the Writ Petition and thus render justice.

Dated at Chennai, this the 10th day of September 2013

Counsel for the petitioner. 



14 January 2012

Deaths confirm cancer risk near (Kalpakkam) N-reactors - DNA investigations

After being in denial for years, the department of atomic energy (DAE) has for the first time admitted that the deaths of its employees at the Kalpakkam nuclear site and their dependents were because of multiple myeloma, a rare form of bone marrow cancer linked to nuclear radiation.

In response to a Right to Information (RTI) query in October last year, the DAE said nine people, including three employees working at the Kalpakkam atomic reactor, about 70km from Chennai, died of multiple myeloma and bone cancer between 1995 and 2011. The department had earlier refused to divulge information despite an RTI query in 2010.

The risk to the lives of people working at the nuclear facilities at Kalpakkam came to the fore in 2003 when two of its employees — Mohandas and Ponniah — working at the reactor died of multiple myeloma after being exposed to nuclear radiation. DAE officials then denied that the deaths were because of overexposure to radiation.

While two people were detected with multiple myeloma when they were working at the reactor, another was found to have the rare form of bone marrow cancer after retirement. The RTI query revealed that 14 people, including 11 family members of employees at Kalpakkam nuclear facilities, have been detected with multiple myeloma and bone cancer between 1995 and 2011.

Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC) officials, however, claim that there have been no deaths due to exposure to radiation at Kalpakkam. They even said the figure of people affected by radiation at the nuclear facilities was lesser than the national average of 1-4 per 1 lakh people.

“The figure of three employees at Kalpakkam having multiple myeloma during 16-17 years is not higher than the normal prevalence of such form of cancer among others, in India or abroad,” BARC said in its response.
Experts, however, said it was a faulty comparison and that it was not possible to compare such sensitive data to the national average. As per international standards, cancer cases because of radiation are computed by comparing people living in proximate villages to those living in villages far away from the nuclear facilities, said Dr V Pugazhenthi, a physician who has been practising in Kalpakkam for 20 years.

Going by international standards, a DAE-funded study by Dr Manjula Datta shows that the number of people in proximity to Kalpakkam nuclear facilities suffering from cancer is a cause of concern. DNA is in possession of the report that was never made public.

The report states that cancer cases in villages close to Kalpakkam are seven times higher (210 per 1 lakh people) compared to just (30 per 1 lakh people) in distant villages. Morbidity levels in areas near the nuclear reactor are 2-3 times higher than normal. The study covered 22 proximate villages (within 8km radius) and three distant villages (50km from the reactor site).

“Several cases of cancer due to nuclear radiation have come up in the vicinity of the Kalpakkam nuclear reactor, but they were never reported. Even when they were reported, the government refused to acknowledge them,” said VT Padmanabhan a researcher in health effects of radiation and member of the European Commission on Radiation Risk.

“Dr Datta’s report is one of the best independent surveys carried out to date. Going by its data, it is clear that radiation causes cancer.”

Data sought from the DAE under a separate RTI reveals as many as 244 Kalpakkam employees and their dependents were detected with various types of cancer between 1999 and 2009. Most people affected were in the 41-60 age group and included men as well as women. During 2000-2010, 19 cases of thyroid diseases were detected. Experts said thyroid diseases are common among people living in and around nuclear reactor sites.

BARC officials, however, said the 244 cancer cases and mortality rates among Kalpakkam employees were not different from those seen among the general population.

Nuclear Power Corporation of India Ltd officials did not respond to questions mailed by DNA to their official ids despite several reminders.

- Gangadhar S Patil

02 December 2011

I am a doctor, being victimized for telling radiation truth: Dr. V. Pugazhenthi from Kalpakkam

Dr. V. Pugazhenthi is acclaimed for doing rigorous and credible studies on health impact of radiation around Kalpakkam nuclear site. He is one of the members of people’s expert committee in the ongoing anti-nuclear movement in Koodankulam. We have been publishing Dr. Pugazhenthi’s articles, jointly written with Dr. V T Padmanabhan and Dr. R. Ramesh on DiaNuke.org in last few months. It is unfortunate that he is being victimized to this extent. From the past, we know about the story of Dr. B K Subbarao’s victimization at the hands of the nuclear establishment.
Here are some of Dr. Pugazhenthi’s recent articles:
And here is an article from Outlook Magazine about Dr. Pugazhenthii’s selfless medical work among the rural poor.


Dr. V. Pugazhenthi MBBS,
1/187, Mudhaliyar Street,
Sadras, Kanchipuram District,
Tamil Nadu, India - 603 102

Ph: 8870578769

To: All the Democratically Concerned People of Tamil Nadu, India and the World

Respected Friend, Madam/Sir:

Subject: False Charges filed on me to curtail my professional and democratic duty to warn the people I am serving about the ill effects of the nuclear radiation around the Kalpakkam Nuclear Power Plant*

I am a medical doctor practicing in Sadras village near the Kalpakkam Nuclear Power Plant in Tamil Nadu, India, since 1989. I was a gold medalist during my undergraduate years at Madurai Medical College, but chose not to pursue higher education because I felt I should work among the poor masses in the villages. I chose Sadras as the place for my practice since I had many friends at Kalpakkam, who happened to work in the Kalpaakam Nuclear Power Plant.

From 1989 to 2000, my professional work was focused principally on serving the Dalit and the Fisher folks. My interests were in Primary Heath Care and I had devised many innovative cost efficient methods to treat the most prevalent diseases among the masses. I had written profusely about these methods in many journals and have published books highlighting these. My work was recognised by the local and national media and they had interviewed me many a times with regard to this. The noted magazine “Outlook” conducting a survey on the incidence of Polydactyly ( people with more than 5 fingers/toes in each hand or foot) in this region. This was early 2001 and was related to the public hearing process for the Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor scheduled to be held on 27 July 2001.

The survey showed a very high incidence and this made me plunge into studying the effects of radiation among the local populace. I have not looked back ever since and have conducted many a health surveys since. I have remained a whistle blower who have ardently asked the Nuclear Power Plant authorities to follow nationally and internationally accepted safety codes. Appreciating my work, I have been asked to become the technical and medical consultant to a group of concerned local citizens on the ill effects of radiation. This group called “ Anuk Kathirveechu Paathukaappukkaana Makkal Iyakkam” (Peoples Movement for Protection Against Nuclear Radiation)” is to conduct a protest on 12 November 2011 against the breech of nationally and internationally laid safety codes by the authorities of the Kalpakkam Nuclear Power Plant. Their contention has valid scientific proofs. People belonging to this movement are working for the past one month to make this protest a successful one.

It is in this background, I received a telephone call at 6 PM on 1 December 2011 from the Puthupattinam police station. The police inspector Mr.Siva Kumar, told me that the Puthupattinam Panchayat Chief had filed a petition against me and whether I could go to the Police Station for an enquiry in this regard. I was busy in my clinic and told him once my works were over I would meet him at the station. I went to the police station at 7.30 PM. I was asked to wait. The police inspector then telephoned the panchayat chief. He arrived at the station by 8..10 PM. The enquiry lasted for about 30 minutes. I left the place by 8.50 PM.

The police inspector narrated the charges filed against me by Mr.Kaliaperumal :
  1. Mr.Kaliyaperumal, the Panchayat Chief of Puthupattinam village has filed a petition against me and one Mr.Nehru. He is charging us both that we had threatened to murder him if he does not cooperate with out anti nuclear work.
  2. The alleged threat was sent to him in the form of an anonymous letter, which he said was penned by Mr.Nehru under my direction.
  3. An SMS to his mobile phone from an unknown mobile phone number had also threatened to murder him. This is also alleged to have been sent by someone close to me under my directions.
  4. Many SMS notes keep coming to his mobile phone from unknown numbers abusing him. He believes that all these SMS notes are sent to him under my directions.
I gave the following replies to the police inspector with respect to the above charges:

I do not involve myself in any anti nuclear work. I am only discharging my professional service by telling everyone about the findings culled from my two decade long work and critical studies related to health and nuclear radiation in general and Kalpakkam Nuclear Power Plant in particular. I am not an organiser of any anti nuclear movement but am and will remain a technical and medical consultant of such movements. Recently I have been asked by People’s Movement Against Nuclear Energy that spearheads people’s agitation against Kudankulam Nuclear Power Project, to share my professional experiences as one of its panel of experts. 

Like this, I have shared my experiences and studies with people all around the country.

I have met the Panchayat Chief Mr.Kaliaperumal on various occasions. I have even congratulated him on the day he had won the local election. I have talked to him cordially always. I have explained to him as I explain to everyone I meet, about the issue of nuclear radiation around. As I work as a medical professional and not as a political organiser, where does the question of me threatening him to join my work? My work is to treat, study and share. Where does his charge fit in?

However, as you are asking me a particular question, I state here that I have not at any moment threatened Mr.Kaliaperumal to join an anti nuclear agitation.

I have nothing to do with the anonymous letter that threatens Mr.Kaliaperumal with death. I know Mr.Nehru, but under no circumstance he is working with me. The charge that Mr.Nehru wrote this letter under my influence is a concocted lie.

I have nothing to do with any of the SMS notes that are alleged to be received by Mr.Kaliaperumal.
As I finished with my reply, the police inspector said he has not filed the First Information Report. However, he asked me to give in writing that “I would be present at the police station whenever I am summoned by him for further enquiries. If I am not present for such enquiries, then I agree that the charges kept on me is true.” I told him what that would mean to my daily professional schedule. I explained to him how the poor patients who come to see me from miles afar would deeply suffer. However, he insisted that I should give this in writing. At last, as a good samaritan,I gave him in writing that whenever he summons me I would be present at the police station.

Once I gave him this written note, he told me in a very harsh warning voice: “Doctor! Do you know that I can book you under National Security Act for whatever the works that you are doing? By the way…. Have you ever heard anything about “police encounter”? So, be careful.”

I remain baffled. However, there’s no way my professional and democratic work can be suspended by any force whatever.

I strongly suspect the hand of the authorities of the Kalpakkam Nuclear Power Plant behinnd all this. They are particularly disturbed by the facts I have recently published with respect to the safety codes being practiced by them. They are, I suspect, disturbed by a news that I am about to publish a book that is to question the various safety issues related with the power plant. I think, by intimidating me with such police threats, they believe that they will be able to make the Kalpakkam environment radiologically safe.

I have been open always for discussion with the authorities of the power plant. I have met them many a times and have always shared all the data available with me. However, they have, over the past 10 years have not tried to answer any of my questions in the earnest. Now, I suspect, that they have decided to opt other means to silence my work.

It is in this regard, I request all of you – my democratically minded brethren – to pray and voice for me and my family members.

Sincerely Yours

Dr.V.Pugazhenthi MBBS
Puthupattinam,
Kanchipuram, Tamil Nadu, India
2 December 2011

11 November 2011

Kalpakkam - PIL to implement Disaster Management Guidelines of Nuclear and Radiological Emergencies

In the High Court of Judicature at Madras
(Special Original Jurisdiction)


W.P. No.  26097 of 2011


M.Vetri Selvan
Advocate
No.300/183, 2nd Floor,
Thambu Chetty Street,
Chennai. 600 001                                                               .. Petitioner

vs


1. Union of India
rep. by the Secretary
Ministry of Home Affairs, North Block
Central Secretariat
New Delhi 110 001

2. Union of India
represented by the Secretary
Department of Atomic Energy
Anushakti Bhavan
Chatrapathi Shivaji Maharaj Marg
Mumbai 400 001

3.National Disaster Management Authourity 
rep. by the Chairman
NDMA Bhavan
A-1, Safdajung Enclave
New Delhi

4. State of Tamil Nadu
rep. by the Chief Secretary
Secretariat
Chennai   600 009

5.  The Principal Secretary/Commissioner
Revenue Administration
Disaster Management and Mitigation
Ezhilagam Building, Chepauk,
 Chennai 600 005

6.  The District Collector
Collectorate
Kancheepuram 631 501                                           … Respondents                                           


AFFIDAVIT

I, M.Vetri Selvan, S/o S.Muthuraj, aged about  29 years, residing at No.32, KVB Garden, R.A.Puram, Chennai 600 028 do hereby on solemn affirmation state as under:

1..    I am the petitioner herein.  I am conversant with the facts of the case.  I am competent to file this affidavit. 

2..    I state that I am an advocate having a standing of more than five years. I am also actively associated with  “Poovulagin Nanbargal”, a registered public trust working for the protection of environment and forests. I am initiating this Public Interest Litigation in discharge of my fundamental duties under Article 51-A (g),   (h) and (j) of the Constitution.    This public interest litigation questions the failure of the respondents to implement the Guidelines on Management of Nuclear and Radiological Emergencies with regard to Madras Atomic Power Station, Kalpakkam, Kancheepuram District.

3.         I state that the Madras Atomic Power Station (MAPS) is located  at Kalpakkam,  about 70 kms  from Chennai City.  The power station consists of two units viz.   MAPS-1 and MAPS-2. MAPS-1 AND MAPS-2 went critical in 1983 and 1985 respectively.  At Kalpakkam, there are seven nuclear organizations including MAPS viz. Bharatiya Nabhikiya Vidyut Nigam Ltd. (HQ), Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Research, PFBR Project (IGCAR), Nuclear Desalination Demonstration Plant (BARC), Kalpakkam Fuel Reprocessing Plant (BARC) and General Services Organisation.  Presently, the MAPS produces 440 MW of electricity from the two reactors.  It is learnt that the Union of India has plans for an additional 500 MW capacity in MAPS. 

4.            I state that on 26 March 1999 there was Heavy water leaks in MAPS and seven people received a full radiation dose. According to Dr. A. Gopalakrishnan, former Chairman of the Atomic Energy Regulatory Board, in the early 1980s, the discovery of some pieces of zircalloy in a moderator pump in MAPS Unit 1 was traced to the problem of substantial crackingof the reactor inlet manifold and an identical problem surfaced in MAPS-2 also almost during the same period and that the synergy of different kinds of serious safety issues in MAPS 1 and 2 put the station at a higher risk than acceptable anywhere else in the world.  

Frontline, a fortnightly in English, (March 16-23, 1999) reported  about Dr. A. Gopalakrishnan’s view about the said heavy water leak in MAPS:  “Gopalakrishnan said that going by the initial estimates given by MAPS, several tones, possibly 14 tonnes, of heavy water leaked out.  “For this number the declaration of a plant emergency makes sense,” he said.  “You will not declare a plant emergency if just one bucketful of heavy water leaks or about 10 workers are concerned.  A very large amount must have gone into the drain and spread out.  The (tritium) release must have also been sucked into the ventilation system.”  It reports further:  “Tritium is highly radioactive, with a half-life of over 12 years.  Tritium content in heavy water increases with the number of years the reactor operates.  Almost all the tritium continues to be in the heavy water even if the reactor is shut down for a couple of months.  When there is a spillage of heavy water, the tritium affects the plant personnel.”  Dr. A. Gopalakrishnan, on account of the fact that micro-cracks in the coolant tubes would ultimately lead to a fire in the reactor, expressed great concern about the workers also.  The report says: “He demanded that personnel in MAPS be given the data on the release of radiation and be told how much radiation they had ingested.  He said that he was deeply concerned about the use of contract labour for cleaning jobs because they were often overexposed to radiation.”

5.       I state that even after such caution by the former Chairman of Atomic Energy Regulatory Board, there were two more incidents in 2001 and 2002.  On 30 May 2001, one Mr.S. Sivakumar, a worker, suffered internal contamination after a neoprene glove was punctured.  On 7 July 2002, one Selvakumar, a worker, burnt his left hand after he picked up a radioactive substance.  Moreover, as reported in Tehelka (2010), the General Secretary of the BARC Facilities Employees Association in his letter dated 24 January 2003 addressed to the Director of Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC) recounted in detail a significant nuclear accident that took place on 21 January 2003 at MAPS where one worker named Raju and 5 others including a woman were exposed to high levels of radiation.  After about eight months of the accident, Mr.B. Bhattacharjee, then Director of BARC, termed it “the worst accident in India’s nuclear history.”

6.            I state that an  estimated 30,000 workers live in the five villages that fall within the 5 km radius from MAPS.  There is a DAE township which accommodates thousands of permanent workers and their families.  Within the 16 km to 20 km radius from MAPS, there are about 60 villages where more than 1 lakh people live.  Since plant operations begain in the early 1980s, incidents of cancer and auto-immune thyroid diseases in the surrounding villages have increased.  A contract labour’s three year old child has been diagnosed with retinoblastoma or cancer of eyes.  Radiation from the nuclear plant is responsible for the child’s condition, doctors say.  Life of thousands of innocent people living in the villages which are within the radius of about 16 km to 20 km  from MAPS is at stake.  Considering the fact that nuclear emergencies can arise due to factors beyond the control of the operating agencies  e.g. human error, system, failure, sabotage, earthquake, cyclone, flood etc., the National Disaster Management Authority has assumed the responsibility of strengthening the existing nuclear/radiological emergency management framework by framing fresh guidelines on Management of Nuclear and Radiological Emergencies.  Radiological emergencies at nuclear installations are mainly of four categories:  Plant Emergency Alert, Plant Emergency, Site Emergency and Off-site Emergency.  The Operating Organisation is responsible for handling Plant Emergency Alert, Plant Emergency and Site Emergency.  Off-site emergency involving radiation fallout in the public domain is handled by state public authorities with technical input and guidance from the Operating Organisation and the Regulatory Body.

7.         I state that the National Disaster Management Guidelines on Management of Nuclear and Radiological Emergencies (for short, the Guidelines) deserve to be implemented in the light of the objects sought to be achieved by the Disaster Management Act, 2005 (for short, the Act). Under Section 6 of the Act, the National Disaster Management Authority is required to take all measures for the prevention of disaster or the mitigation, or preparedness and capacity building for dealing with the threatening disaster situation or disaster.  It is incumbent upon the National Authority to coordinate the enforcement and implementation of the policy and plan for disaster management. The Executive Summary of the Guidelines says that the guidelines related to capacity development through education and awareness generation, training and community participation etc. for upgradation of human resources, establishment of critical infrastructure like expansion of the network of Emergency Response Centres, communication systems, strengthening of regulatory framework and emergency medical preparedness including formation of Quick Reaction Medical Teams etc. should be implemented by December 2010.  However, the respondents have not even implemented the Guidelines regarding “Medical Preparedness” which is an essential component of nuclear disaster/radiological emergency/disaster preparedness.  Hence this Writ Petition in public interest on the following ground:

GROUND

         It is submitted that paragraph 6.13 (viii) of the Guidelines says:”The existing medical facilities and medical professionals are highly inadequate to handle large-scale radiation injury cases in the country.  These are to be augmented by MoH&FW in consultation with DAE at the primary, secondary and tertiary levels, in addition to their proper networking to cope with the needs of a large-scale nuclear emergency.”  Paragraph 6.13 (ix) says: “The district health authorities will constitute QRMTs for pre-hospital care.  The team consisting of RSOs, medical doctors, nurses and paramedical staff would be equipped with monitoring instruments/equipment, protective gear, decontamination agents and other material.  Critical care vans with resuscitation and life support systems will be part of QRMTs/MFRs.  The QRMT/MFR teams will form part of the regular mock-drill/simulation exercise/tabletop exercise conducted by DDMAs.”  

Appendix 4  to the Guidelines captioned “Medical Preparedness” speaks about Creation of Decontamination Room, Nuclear Ward fitted with Dust-Filter, Radioactive Bio-Waste Disposal Facilities, Radio Bio-Dosimetry Laboratory, Haematology Laboratory, Genetic Laboratory, Molecular Laboratory, Immunology Laboratory,  and Bone Marrow Bank, Bone Marrow Transfusion and Stem Cell Harvesting Facilities in the earmarked hospital.  The respondents have not earmarked any hospital with the aforesaid facilities which will be used by those affected by radiation due to the operation of MAPS. 

The respondents have not established  near MAPS any Specialised Medical Stores consisting of Amifostine and other radio protectors, de-corporation agents like Diethylene Triamine-PentaAcetate (DTPA) and Prussian Blue), Potassium lodide, growth factors, colony stimulating factors, and other radiation recovery agents, as required by the Guidelines relating to Medical Preparedness. The respondents have not established any Research and Treatment Centre near MAPS with sufficient number of beds to take care of any type of nuclear emergency/disaster, as required by the Guidelines.  

Though the Guidelines say that such centres should be established in at least four geographically well-separated locations near the high-risk areas/zones, the respondents have not taken any efforts to implement the Guidelines.  The respondents have not fulfilled the specific requirements of a nuclear emergency communication system as mandated by the Guidelines. Thus, the respondents have grossly failed to implement Chapter 6 of the Guidelines relating to Medical Preparedness.  This failure of the respondents would be violative of Article 21 of the Constitution.     

8.    I state that I have no equally efficacious alternative remedy but to approach the Hon'ble Court by way of this writ petition.

9.    I state that I have not filed any other petition in this Hon'ble Court or any other Court regarding the subject matter of this writ petition.

10.    I state that I have no personal interest in the case.  I have earlier filed a couple of public interest litigations viz. WP No. 14866/2009 decided on 22.07.2010 by the Hon’ble the Chief Justice and the Hon’ble Justice T.S.Sivagnanam (M.Vetri Selvan Vs. Union of India and others : 2010 (4) CTC 465 and W.P. No. 19192 of 2010 decided on 16.11.2010., decided by Hon’ble the Chief Justice and the Hon’ble Justice T.S.Sivagnanam.  I have also filed WP No. 8034/ 2011 decided on 01.04.2011 by the  Hon’ble the Chief Justice and the Hon’ble Justice T.S.Sivagnanam (M.Vetri Selvan Vs. Union of India and others : 2011 (3) CTC 785.  I undertake to pay the costs, if any, if this PIL is found to be intended for personal gain or oblique motive.  I have filed this petition from my own funds.  To my knowledge, no PIL arising on the issue raised in this petition has been filed anywhere.  On 15.4.2011 and 17.4.2011 I visted Kalpakkam Township and talked to the residents and also visited the Department of Atomic Energy Hospital located in the township.  On 18.6.2011 I visited Sadhurangapattinam and Koovathur villages which are within the radius of 10 km from MAPS and saw for myself that the Primary Health Centres did not have any facilities for treating those affected by radiation.    I verified the facts regarding inadequacy of medical facilities to treat the radiation-affected persons by having discussions with doctors working in Mamallapuram,  and Thirukazhukundram,(within a radius of 25 kms from MAPS)  and also the doctors of Government General Hospital, Chennai.  This public interest litigation is maintainable in law. The contents of this paragraph are in compliance with the Rules to regulate the Public Interest Litigations filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.



Solemnly affirmed at Chennai                                                       Before me
this the 10th November 2011
and signed his name in my
presence.           
                                                                                  Advocate, Chennai












In the High Court of Judicature at Madras
(Special Original Jurisdiction)


W.P. No.  26097   of 2011


M.Vetri Selvan
Advocate
No.300/183, 2nd Floor,
Thambu Chetty Street,
Chennai. 600 001                                                                  .. Petitioner

Vs


1 Union of India
rep. by the Secretary
Ministry of Home Affairs, North Block
Central Secretariat
New Delhi 110 001  & 5 Others                                            … Respondent


           WRIT PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION

1..    The address for service of the petitioner is that of his counsel  M.Radhakrishnan, Advocate,  134, Thambu Chetty Street, Chennai. 600 001.

2..    The address for service on the respondent is as stated above.

    For the reasons stated in the accompanying affidavit, it is prayed that the Hon'ble Court be pleased to issue a WRIT OF  MANDAMUS directing the respondents to implement Chapter 6 of National Disaster Management Guidelines on Management of Nuclear and Radiological Emergencies relating to Medical Preparedness in and around the Madras Atomic Power Station, Kalpakkam, Kancheepuram District, Tamil Nadu within a reasonable time as may be determined by the Hon’ble Court, and thus render justice.

Dated at Chennai, this the 10th day of November  2011

Counsel for  the petitioner

18 May 2011

Accident Sites - radiation, cancer, blindness, tardiness, cover-ups. The lessons from the Kalpakkam nuclear facility


Pride of India
Kalpakkam’s indigenous nuclear reactors produce electricity for commercial consumption
Pride of India
Kalpakkam’s indigenous nuclear reactors produce electricity for commercial consumption
In the end, loud voices were all that mattered.

After three months of extended discussions, legislators in the Indian Parliament yelled their assent. The Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Bill, 2010 was a legislation.

As India charts its journey towards extended nuclear commerce — the legislation allows India to trade with global private firms in nuclear technology — we highlight key coordinates on the Indian nuclear map as we seek to understand how ready we are to embrace nuclear energy.

Last week’s story, Nuclear energy. Ministries warn they are far from ready, 4 September, laid bare the backroom machinations as the government worked to ensure that the Parliament cleared the draft Nuclear Liability legislation. Amidst the loud public din, voices of government officials warning that they were ill-equipped to deal with nuclear accidents were drowned out. When the legislation was finally passed in the Rajya Sabha, Minister of State for Science and Technology Prithviraj Chavan, attempting to take dissenters on board, declared, “This is not final... We will take care of every single suggestion. If required, the Bill will be changed for the better.”

This week, TEHELKA travels to Kalpakkam and Kudankulam in Tamil Nadu where two nuclear plants are located.

IN AN inconspicuous corner of the Department of Atomic Energy’s (DAE) website is a large map that could easily belong in a student’s science textbook. On the map that captures atomic energy establishments in India, it isn’t difficult to find Kalpakkam. Located around 70 km from Tamil Nadu’s capital, Chennai, Kalpakkam plays host to seven nuclear organisations — from the Madras Atomic Power Station that generates nuclear energy to the Kalpakkam Atomic Reprocessing Plant that reprocesses spent fuel from the reactors for reuse in other nuclear programmes. But there is yet another reason to accord Kalpakkam a special place on the Indian nuclear map. The two pressurised heavy water reactors installed at Kalpakkam were developed indigenously. Commercial operation at the atomic power plant began way back in 1984 and 1986; and currently the plant produces 440MW of electricity from the two reactors. Plans for an additional 500MW capacity are on the anvil.

PLAYING WITH SAFETY
> 1995 Dayanidhi and Khandhasamy record 50 times more than normal gamma radiation levels in Kalpakkam
> 26 MARCH 1999 Heavy water leak in the K5 unit of MAPS II. At least seven people received a full radiation dose
> 30 MAY 2001 S Sivakumar, a worker, suffers internal contamination after a neoprene glove is punctured
> 7 JULY 2002 Selvakumar, a worker, burns his left hand after he picks up a radioactive substance
> 19 DECEMBER 2002 Madhusoodanan and Rajan fail to follow safety procedures; suffer internal contamination
Further south, about 700 km from Kalpakkam, is Kudankulam. The Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited is in the process of constructing two 1,000MW capacity reactors here. Kudankulam reactors, being built with the support of the Russian nuclear vendor company, Atomstroyexport, will be India’s first collaboration with an international player when it begins operations in March 2011. The atomic power plants at Kalpakkam and Kudankulam then present two distinct coordinates within the Indian nuclear energy spectrum — a predominantly indigenous-technology powered Kalpakkam power plant versus a power plant that will bring on board collaboration with a foreign player.

And yet as TEHELKA found when it travelled to both places, the anxieties and the pain in the voices of the people living around these plants did not differ. If at Kalpakkam, whispers of nuclear incidents and accidents at the various nuclear facilities were very audible, at Kudankulam, it was the apprehension of an impending disaster that rang clear.

TEHELKA ACCESSED a confidential letter (BARCFEA/ 03/03/131 dated 24 January 2003) written to the Director of Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC), the Mumbai-based organisation that oversees operations at the Kalpakkam Fuel Reprocessing Plant. The letter written by the general secretary of the BARC Facilities Employees’ Association recounted in detail a significant nuclear accident that took place on 21 January 2003 at the Kalpakkam Atomic Reprocessing Plant. According to the letter, a scientist, Srinivasa Raju, was asked to collect a sample of an unknown solution from a low-level radioactive waste tank. The tank had not been fitted with a gamma monitor that would raise an alarm in case of high radiation levels. Around 12 pm, Raju carried the sample to an internal laboratory by hand and left it in a tray for testing. The laboratory’s gamma monitor immediately began emitting visual alarms in response to the high-radiation level of the solution. It took the workers two hours to notice the radiation monitors. By the time, the source of the alarm was located, Raju had been working with the solution for nearly an hour. Besides Raju, five others, including a woman, had also been exposed to high levels of radiation. BARC officials acknowledged the event eight months later, and finally on 6 August 2003, B Bhattacharjee, then director of BARC, termed it “the worst accident in India’s nuclear history”.

A sorry sight A cancerous eye will eventually claim the life of three-year-old Abhi, warn medical experts
A sorry sight A cancerous eye will eventually claim the life of three-year-old Abhi, warn medical experts
When we asked about the six people, including Raju, who were exposed to high levels of radiation, there were no easy answers. “One of them died,” said Dr A Vijaya, medical superintendent of the DAE established hospital in Kalpakkam, only to quickly add, “but not due to radiation. The rest are fine.” Deflecting queries about their whereabouts, Dr Vijaya directed us to the fuel reprocessing plant officials. Repeated attempts to contact the reprocessing plant officials proved futile.

Yet another Confidential letter reveals more cases of radiation exposure (see box). In an off-hand dismissal of accident claims by workers at the plant, Dr Vasudev Rao, Director, Chemical Group, Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Research in Kalpakkam said the Indian nuclear industry had a zero-tolerance policy towards radiation exposure. “Because of our clean track record, even small instances are blown out of proportion by the media and common people,” said Dr Rao.

Outside the facility too, there are enough voices that speak of radiation effects. Since plant operations began in the early 1980s, incidents of cancer and auto-immune thyroid diseases in the surrounding villages have increased. Five km south of the Kalpakkam nuclear facility, at Sadraskuppam village, we met with Rajesh (name changed), a contract worker at the nuclear facility. Rajesh’s three-year-old daughter, Abhi has been diagnosed with retinoblastoma, or cancer of eyes, and doctors have just confirmed the eventuality of her death.

NUCLEAR CLOUD
PREVIOUSLY
MINISTRIES WARN
THEY ARE FAR
FROM READY
by SANJANA
NEXT WEEK
GROUND REPORT
FROM INDIA’S
NUCLEAR PARK
by NIKHIL GHANEKAR
“I want to donate her organs. But my wife is far too emotional and won’t hear of it,” he says. Rajesh earns 300 daily — a sum that is hardly enough to pay for an operation that could have possibly saved his daughter’s life.

A second-generation plant worker, Rajesh tells us emphatically that doctors treating his daughter at the Aarvind Eye Hospital in Madurai unequivocally confirm that radiation from the nuclear plant is responsible for her condition. Their advice is clear — move out of the area. Something that Rajesh cannot afford to do. “I have four young children who depend on me. How will I feed them if I don’t work here?” asks Rajesh. Point out the obvious irony and Rajesh turns away.

For the nation
Kudankulam will have four
more 1,000 MW capacity
nuclear reactors, bringing
the total number to six
For the nation Kudankulam will have four more 1,000 MW capacity nuclear reactors, bringing the total number to six
Rajesh’s story is by no means an isolated one. An estimated 30,000 workers live in the five villages that fall within the 5 km radius from the plant, besides a DAE township that accommodates permanent plant workers. Ask for statistics on cancer-related deaths among workers and the local public health centre refuses our requests on grounds classifying the information as sensitive. The DAE medical officer, Dr Vijaya, claims that the number of cancer cases in the township is an insignificant 244 over a 10-year period. Local activists contest the figure and say that the official list excludes many deaths. The cause of death is often changed to keep numbers down. Activists and DAE officials also do not see eye-to-eye on the causes of diseases that are prevalent here. Despite studies by internationally recognised professionals, DAE officials maintain that the radiation levels emitted are too low to cause problems.

Though it hasn’t been officially announced, 30,000 villagers have been asked to leave once the Kudankulam plant gets ready
NONE OF these debates were taken on board by the parliamentary committee that visited the facility on 7 July this year while the nuclear liability legislation was under consideration. Over a few hours, committee members led by T Subbarami Reddy met officials from different facilities and local politicians and concluded that the facility was equipped to handle accidents and that people faced no problems in the area. “We are shocked. They didn’t even enter the villages. They accepted the version of the DAE officials and the politicians,” says Dr V Pugazhenthi, a physician who has been practising in the area for the past 20 years. Understandably, the doctor is a strong critic of the plant’s unsafe practices.

In Kudankulam, months away from the start of the operations, there is no sign of debate. Villagers allege that the mandated public hearings, one possible space for debate, were held 87 km from the plant site. Says AS Ravi, a local leader, “We went in huge numbers despite the obvious problem of distance. Nothing mattered though. In the end, our villages didn’t even figure on their map.” Adds Dr SP Udayakumar, another activist, “People here are bracing for the radiation effects once the plant operations begin in March 2011. Though officially, there has been no intimation, 30,000 villagers have been asked to leave once the plant is functional.”

In the end, for the villagers of Kudankulam, there is only one relevant question left to ask. In broken Hindi, an old banana vendor yells, “If Manmohan Singh thinks nuclear energy is good, why doesn’t he build a plant at 10 Janpath?” One suggestion that Prithviraj Chavan is not going to take on board.

- KUNAL MAJUMDER

Courtesy: Tehelka September 11, 2010