Showing posts with label Cancer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cancer. Show all posts

14 January 2012

Deaths confirm cancer risk near (Kalpakkam) N-reactors - DNA investigations

After being in denial for years, the department of atomic energy (DAE) has for the first time admitted that the deaths of its employees at the Kalpakkam nuclear site and their dependents were because of multiple myeloma, a rare form of bone marrow cancer linked to nuclear radiation.

In response to a Right to Information (RTI) query in October last year, the DAE said nine people, including three employees working at the Kalpakkam atomic reactor, about 70km from Chennai, died of multiple myeloma and bone cancer between 1995 and 2011. The department had earlier refused to divulge information despite an RTI query in 2010.

The risk to the lives of people working at the nuclear facilities at Kalpakkam came to the fore in 2003 when two of its employees — Mohandas and Ponniah — working at the reactor died of multiple myeloma after being exposed to nuclear radiation. DAE officials then denied that the deaths were because of overexposure to radiation.

While two people were detected with multiple myeloma when they were working at the reactor, another was found to have the rare form of bone marrow cancer after retirement. The RTI query revealed that 14 people, including 11 family members of employees at Kalpakkam nuclear facilities, have been detected with multiple myeloma and bone cancer between 1995 and 2011.

Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC) officials, however, claim that there have been no deaths due to exposure to radiation at Kalpakkam. They even said the figure of people affected by radiation at the nuclear facilities was lesser than the national average of 1-4 per 1 lakh people.

“The figure of three employees at Kalpakkam having multiple myeloma during 16-17 years is not higher than the normal prevalence of such form of cancer among others, in India or abroad,” BARC said in its response.
Experts, however, said it was a faulty comparison and that it was not possible to compare such sensitive data to the national average. As per international standards, cancer cases because of radiation are computed by comparing people living in proximate villages to those living in villages far away from the nuclear facilities, said Dr V Pugazhenthi, a physician who has been practising in Kalpakkam for 20 years.

Going by international standards, a DAE-funded study by Dr Manjula Datta shows that the number of people in proximity to Kalpakkam nuclear facilities suffering from cancer is a cause of concern. DNA is in possession of the report that was never made public.

The report states that cancer cases in villages close to Kalpakkam are seven times higher (210 per 1 lakh people) compared to just (30 per 1 lakh people) in distant villages. Morbidity levels in areas near the nuclear reactor are 2-3 times higher than normal. The study covered 22 proximate villages (within 8km radius) and three distant villages (50km from the reactor site).

“Several cases of cancer due to nuclear radiation have come up in the vicinity of the Kalpakkam nuclear reactor, but they were never reported. Even when they were reported, the government refused to acknowledge them,” said VT Padmanabhan a researcher in health effects of radiation and member of the European Commission on Radiation Risk.

“Dr Datta’s report is one of the best independent surveys carried out to date. Going by its data, it is clear that radiation causes cancer.”

Data sought from the DAE under a separate RTI reveals as many as 244 Kalpakkam employees and their dependents were detected with various types of cancer between 1999 and 2009. Most people affected were in the 41-60 age group and included men as well as women. During 2000-2010, 19 cases of thyroid diseases were detected. Experts said thyroid diseases are common among people living in and around nuclear reactor sites.

BARC officials, however, said the 244 cancer cases and mortality rates among Kalpakkam employees were not different from those seen among the general population.

Nuclear Power Corporation of India Ltd officials did not respond to questions mailed by DNA to their official ids despite several reminders.

- Gangadhar S Patil

03 November 2011

Thyroid Cancer Corridor in India and the Chernobyl Iodine Fallout

Cancer is a disease caused by mutation. Some 200 genes out of an estimated 30,000 genes in the human genomes have been linked to cancers. There are four types of cells in our body. These are stem cells, dividing cells, working cells and dead cells. The outer layer of the skin is composed of dead cells. Stem cells are those that will divide some time in future and become adult cells. Sperm and ovum are also stem cells, but they will divide in another body (embryo/fetus). Stem cells that will become blood in future are stored in bone marrow.
Only mutations on the stem cells and dividing cells can cause cancers. According to the current understanding, at least two genes in the same cell need to be mutated to cause cancer. Such mutations can be caused by ionizing radiations, chemicals like benzene and also some virus. Cancer can occur between a few days and several years after the exposures. After a mass exposure like atomic bombing or nuclear accident, a statistically visible increase can be found after two-three years. Then the incidence peaks in 20-25 years and then it declines. Cancers attributable to radiation are still surfacing among the people in Hiroshima-Nagasaki, 65 years after the bombings.
Generally more women suffer from cancer than men. This is because of the cancer proneness of the female reproductive organs. This is also the case with thyroid – an organ present in both sexes. In Kerala for instance, cancer of the thyroid is about 2 to 3% of the total cancer. It is about 6% in women.
The regional cancer centre (RCC) Thiruvananthapuram has a hospital based cancer registry. The registry data is periodically published by the Indian Council for Medical Research (ICMR). We analyzed RCC data for all cancers and thyroid cancers diagnosed during 1984 to 2003. The data was divided into four periods – 1984-93, 1994-98, 1999-2000 and 2001-03 and compared the incidence of all cancers and thyroid cancer across these periods. The results are given in graph below:
The first graph shows thyroid cancer as percentage of thyroid cancer to the total cancer load in men and women during the four periods. There is more or less a parallel increase of thyroid cancer in both sexes.
The second graph shows the percentage increase over the first period (1984-92) of all cancers and thyroid cancer in men and women during 1994-98, 1999-2000 and 2001-03. All cancers registered an increase in both men and women, but the increase cancer of thyroid is dramatic and highly visible.
Similar increases have been reported in the entire Western Ghats region and the Indian Council for Medical Research (ICMR) has named it as the Thyroid Cancer Corridor of India. We named it, but we do not know who sired it.
WHO DONE IT
On 26 April 1986, there was a ‘chemical’ explosion in a 1000 MW nuclear reactor at Chernobyl in Ukraine. About 20% of the radioactive materials inside the reactor escaped to the atmosphere and was lofted to 3 km in the troposphere. The total radioactivity released in the explosion was 1.5E+19 Bq. (If you are not familiar with this language, remove the decimal after 1 and add 18 zeros to the left of 5. You can also say 15 billion billion Becquerel. Becquerel = one nuclear disintegration in a second) Hundreds of radioisotopes were released. But more important from a public health perspective were radioactive iodine and cesium. 131Iodine ( half life – 8.3 days) accounted for 10% of the total release (1.5 billion billion Bq).
Winds in the middle troposphere carried the radionuclides to almost all parts of the Northern hemisphere. On 5th of May 1986, the air samplers at the Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Research (IGCAR) showed Chernobyl iodine. Next day, the scientists also found it in the thyroid of goats. (They have been collecting goat thyroid from the butchers around Kalpakkam regularly)
So the Chernobyl iodine and cesium was in the lower troposphere over India during May 1986. Rain is a medium that brings radio-iodine and similar nanoparticles from the air to the ground. Wind also does it, but less efficiently. During mid-May, the Western Ghats region receives the summer showers. The rains also brought in radionuclides. Drinking water and milk were two important medium of transfer of iodine to the population. Detailed data on fallout of Chernobyl radionuclides in different parts of India is not available. Thyroid dose to Children from Chernobyl fallout is given in graph below. India is also there, second from the right. Since the half life of 131 Iodine is 8.3 days, regions that receive South West Monsoon rains during May-June received most of the fallout. Incidentally, this rainfall and fallout was observed in UK and other places in Europe.
Source : Annex J of UNSCEAR, 2000. www.unscear.org
Once inside the mammalian body, radioactive iodine behaves exactly like the stable iodine which is part of the diet. It goes to the thyroid. Cesium is chemically similar to potassium. So it goes to almost all parts of the body. Cancer of the thyroid is very rare in children. The background incidence is about 1 case per million children. A hundred fold increase in thyroid cancer was registered in children in Belarus during 20 years after the accident.
We have not been able to locate any other etiological agent for the sudden and dramatic increase in the incidence of thyroid cancer in Trivandrum and other parts of the Western Ghats. Hence we hypothesize that Chernobyl iodine did it.
-VT Padmanabhan, R Ramesh and V Pugazhendi