|
|
Us
|
Them
|
|
Actors
|
Fisherfolk, farmers,
workers, Dalits, Muslims, women, children etc.
Supporters in Tamil
Nadu, Kerala, and rest of India.
Supporting political
parties,
Social movements, Human
rights groups etc.
Some sections of Media
Some international
friends
|
Government of India
Government of Tamil
Nadu
Army, Navy, Air
Force, Coast Guard, CISF, Tamil Nadu Police, Central and State intelligence
agencies etc.
Atomic Energy
Commission, DAE, NPCIL, AERB etc.
Political parties such
as Congress, BJP, DMK, AIADMK etc.
Indian Bureaucracy
Much of Indian Media
US, Russia, France
governments
MNCs of these countries
Spy agencies of these
counties
IAEA etc.
|
|
Positions
|
Nuclear power is bad,
ugly and expensive.
Nuclear power plant is
dangerous and unwanted.
Let us think like a
creative leader and look beyond thermal and nuclear energy.
Let’s consider ‘New
Energies’.
Let’s put Indian
citizens’ interests first.
|
Nuclear power is good,
clean and cheap.
Nuclear power plant is
safe and badly needed.
Let us continue our
colonized thinking and persist with thermal and nuclear energy.
Let’s consider nuclear
energy.
Let’s put foreign
countries’ and their MNCs’ interests first.
|
|
Interests
|
Safeguarding India’s
natural resources such as sea, seafood, land, ground water, air etc.
Protecting ordinary
people’s livelihood and sustainable development.
Ensuring everyone’s
food security, nutrition security, water security etc.
Avoiding health
problems of ordinary people; and protecting the progeny.
Protecting Nature,
Life, Future
|
Producing more
electricity and ensuring energy security and national security.
Promoting the
development agenda of the rich and famous and powerful.
Ensuring the power
brokers’ profits, commissions and kickbacks.
Ignoring such hidden
costs and persisting with short-term gains.
Money, Money, Money
|
|
Gain
|
A few menial jobs
Low income from shops,
services
|
Lots of good jobs
Lots of contracts,
sub-contracts
Money, Power,
Prominence
Electricity
Good
life
|
|
Loss
|
350+ serious cases and
legal hassles
Police action and
harassment
Loss of income and
wealth
Loss of public money on
pro-nuclear campaigns
Loss of privacy and
governmental intrusions
Natural resources
Livelihood
Displacement
Health
Wellbeing of children
and grandchildren
Future
|
|
|
Attacks Faced
|
Dangerous false cases
such as sedition, waging war on the State etc.
Arrests, imprisonment,
torture.
Imprisoning women,
juveniles, and children.
Legal hassles, refusing
bail.
Police searches,
attacks and harassment.
Having anti-social
elements vandalize private properties and homes with police connivance.
Attack on negotiating
team.
Intelligence
departments’ psychological warfare.
Tear gas attack, lathi charge,
firing.
Murder by police.
Aerial harassment of
Coast Guard planes.
Death threats.
|
Nonviolent and peaceful
siege, processions and agitations (for a few hours).
|
|
Slanders Faced
|
Instigated by
opposition parties.
Small group’s protest.
Fishermen struggle.
Christian struggle.
Foreign countries’ and
agencies’ plot.
NGO-funded struggle.
Missionaries’ and
priests’ protest.
Struggle promotes
smuggling in the sea and coasts.
Undertaken to harass
governments.
Struggle promoted by
incentives such as Rs. 500, biriyani and alcohol.
Misguiding innocent
people.
Stubborn and unwilling
to listen.
Receiving foreign
money.
Using human shield.
Character assassination
of leaders, casting aspersions on leaders’ integrity etc.
Accusing of using
violence.
Publishing leaders’
addresses, contact numbers, emails in a newspaper.
Doubting people’s
sanity and sending psychiatrists.
Arresting foreigners
and connecting with struggle.
Linking us with
Naxalites, terrorists, ISI spies etc.
Insulting women and
questioning their morality.
|
|
|
Machinations
|
|
Telling half-truths and
non-truths to people.
Dividing people with
the help of immoral media persons.
Setting up corrupt
media persons against the struggle.
Spreading rumors
and harassing people.
Dividing people along
caste and religious lines.
Trying to instigate
violence in the protest programs.
Trying to ‘buy’ weak
protestors.
Splitting people by
creating gangs and planting goons.
‘Buying’ media and
media persons.
Instigating businessmen
and industrialists against people.
Using scientists and
experts to confuse people.
Setting up proxy
protesters against the struggle.
Setting up religious
leaders to influence people’s opinion.
Distributing freebies.
Canvassing students and
youth in colleges with government influence.
Doing campaigns with
government influence.
Creating artificial
power cuts.
Sending in spies and
agents to endanger peace.
Promising houses, roads
and other “development” projects.
Promising crores of
rupees and wooing panchayat leaders and local leaders to the
government side.
|
|
Favored Solutions
|
Abandon all NPPs
Focus on ‘New Energies’
|
Start more NPPs
Produce nuclear energy
|
|
The Way Out
|
· Announce a moratorium on all nuclear activities all over the country.
· Present a Cost-Benefit-Procedural Impact analysis of NPPs.
· Do financial, energy, environmental, social audit of the existing NPPs.
· Set up an “empowered and independent” regulatory authority.
· Ensure transparency, accountability, and popular participation in nuclear
installations.
· Facilitate a national debate on nuclear deals,
Uranium mines, reactors, waste dumps, and nuclear bombs.
· Let people decide what they need!
|
|
Showing posts with label Alternatives. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alternatives. Show all posts
05 October 2012
The ‘Koodankulam Conflict’ Map
16 January 2012
Hell’s Boilers : It’s time to banish the belief that N-power is clean, green and safe
Fissile Argument
The nuclear power industry has been resurrected over the past decade by a lobbying campaign that has left many people believing it to be a clean, green, emission-free alternative to fossil fuels. These beliefs pose an extraordinary threat to global public health and encourage a major financial drain on national economies and taxpayers. The commitment to nuclear power as an environmentally safe energy source has also stifled the mass development of alternative technologies that are far cheaper, safer and almost emission-free—the future for global energy.
When the Fukushima Daiichi reactors suffered meltdowns in March, literally in the backyard of an unsuspecting public, the stark reality that the risks of nuclear power far outweigh any benefits should have become clear to the world. As the old quip goes, “Nuclear power is one hell of a way to boil water.”
Instead, the nuclear industry has used the disaster to increase its already extensive lobbying efforts. A few nations vowed to phase out nuclear energy after the disaster. But many others have remained steadfast in their commitment to using nuclear power.
That has left millions of innocent people unaware that they—all of us—may face a medical catastrophe beyond all proportions in the wake of Fukushima through the continued widespread use of nuclear energy.
The world was warned of the dangers of nuclear accidents 25 years ago, when Chernobyl exploded and lofted radioactive poisons into the atmosphere. Those poisons “rained out”, creating hot spots over the northern hemisphere. Research by scientists in eastern Europe, collected and published by the New York Academy of Sciences, estimates that 40 per cent of the European landmass is now contaminated with caesium-137 and other radioactive poisons that will concentrate in food for hundreds to thousands of years.
Wide areas of Asia—from Turkey to China—the United Arab Emirates, north Africa and north America are also contaminated. Nearly 200 million people remain exposed.
That research estimated that by now close to a million people have died of causes linked to the Chernobyl disaster. They perished from cancers, congenital deformities, immune deficiencies, infections, cardiovascular diseases, endocrine abnormalities and radiation-induced factors that increased infant mortality. Studies in Belarus found that in 2000, 14 years after the Chernobyl disaster, fewer than 20 per cent of the children were considered “practically healthy”, compared to 90 per cent before Chernobyl.
Now, Fukushima has been called the second-worst nuclear disaster after Chernobyl. Much is still uncertain about the long-term consequences of this disaster. Fukushima may well be on par with or even far exceed Chernobyl in terms of the effects on public health, as new information becomes available. The crisis is ongoing; the plant remains unstable and radiation emissions continue into the air and water.
Recent monitoring by citizens’ groups, international organisations and the US government have found dangerous hotspots in Tokyo and other areas. The Japanese government, meanwhile, in late September lifted evacuation advisories for some areas near the damaged plant—even though high levels of radiation remained. The government estimated that it will spend at least $13 billion to clean up contamination.
Like the Chernobyl meltdown, the accident at Fukushima, too, is of global proportions.
Unusual levels of radiation have been discovered in British Columbia, along the west and east coasts of the US and in Europe, and heavy contamination has been found in oceanic waters.
Fukushima is classified as a Grade-7 accident on the International Atomic Energy Agency scale, denoting “widespread health and environmental effects”. That is the same severity as Chernobyl, the only other Grade-7 accident in history, but such disaster measurement is hazy: there is no higher number on the agency’s scale.
After the accident, lobbying groups touted improved safety at nuclear installations globally. In Japan, the Tokyo Electric Power Co, which operates the Fukushima Daiichi reactors, and the government have sought to control the reporting of negative stories via telecom companies and internet service providers.
In Britain, The Guardian reported that days after the tsunami, companies with interests in nuclear power—Areva, EDF Energy and Westinghouse—worked with the government to downplay the accident, fearing setbacks on plans for new nuclear power plants.
Nuclear power has always been the nefarious Trojan horse for the weapons industry, and effective publicity campaigns are a hallmark of both industries. The concept of nuclear electricity was conceived in the early 1950s as a way to make the public more comfortable with the US development of nuclear weapons. “The atomic bomb will be accepted far more readily if at the same time atomic energy is being used for constructive ends,” a consultant to the Defense Department Psychological Strategy Board, Stefan Possony, suggested.
The phrase ‘Atoms for Peace’ was popularised by President Dwight Eisenhower in the early 1950s.
Nuclear power and nuclear weapons are one and the same technology. A 1,000-MW nuclear reactor generates 600 pounds or so of plutonium per year: an atomic bomb requires a fraction of that amount for fuel, and plutonium remains radioactive for 2,50,000 years. Therefore, every country with a nuclear power plant also has a bomb factory with unlimited potential.
The nuclear power industry sets an unforgivable precedent by exporting nuclear technology—bomb factories—to dozens of non-nuclear nations.
Why is nuclear power still viable, after we’ve witnessed catastrophic accidents, enormous financial outlays, weapons proliferation and nuclear-waste-induced epidemics of cancers and genetic disease for generations to come? Simply put, many government and other officials believe the nuclear industry mantra: safe, clean and green. And the public is not educated on the issue.
There are some signs of change. Germany will phase out nuclear power by 2022. Italy and Switzerland have decided against it, and anti-nuclear advocates in Japan have gained traction. China remains cautious on nuclear power. Yet the nuclear enthusiasm of the United States, Britain, Russia and Canada continues unabated. The industry, meanwhile, has promoted new modular and ‘advanced’ reactors as better alternatives to traditional reactors. They are, however, subject to the very same risks—accidents, terrorist attacks, human error—as the traditional reactors. Many also create fissile material for bombs as well as the legacy of radioactive waste.
True green, clean, nearly emission-free solutions exist for providing energy. They lie in a combination of conservation and renewable energy sources—mainly wind, solar and geothermal, hydropower plants and biomass from algae. A smart-grid could make possible the integration of consuming and producing devices, allowing flexible operation of household appliances. The problem of intermittent power can be solved by storing energy using available technologies.
Millions of jobs can be created by replacing nuclear power with nationally integrated, renewable energy systems. In the United States alone, this project could be paid for by the $180 billion currently allocated for nuclear weapons programmes over the next decade. In fact, there would be no need for new weapons if the Russian and American nuclear arsenals—95 per cent of the estimated 20,500 nuclear weapons globally—are abolished.
Advocates of nuclear energy often paint those who oppose them as Luddites who are afraid of, or do not understand, modern technology, or as hysterics who disproportionately exaggerate the dangers of nuclear power. One might recall the sustained attack over many decades by the tobacco industry upon the medical profession—a profession that revealed the grave health dangers induced by smoking. Smoking, broadly speaking, only kills the smoker, active or passive. Nuclear power bequeaths morbidity and mortality—epidemics of disease—to all future generations. The millions of lives lost to smoking in the era before the health risks of cigarettes were widely exposed will be minuscule compared to the medical catastrophe we face through the continued use of nuclear power.
Let’s use this extraordinary moment to convince governments and others to move toward a nuclear-free world. Let’s prove that informed democracies will behave in a responsible fashion.
(Helen Caldicott, Paediatrician, founder-president, Physicians for Social Responsibility, anti-nuclear activist)
Courtesy: Outlook Magazine, Jan 02, 2012
- The N-industry calls nuclear energy “clean and green”
- Being taken in by this poses a global danger—to ecology, health, and economies
- Money would be better spent on R&D in renewable energy
***
When the Fukushima Daiichi reactors suffered meltdowns in March, literally in the backyard of an unsuspecting public, the stark reality that the risks of nuclear power far outweigh any benefits should have become clear to the world. As the old quip goes, “Nuclear power is one hell of a way to boil water.”
Instead, the nuclear industry has used the disaster to increase its already extensive lobbying efforts. A few nations vowed to phase out nuclear energy after the disaster. But many others have remained steadfast in their commitment to using nuclear power.
That has left millions of innocent people unaware that they—all of us—may face a medical catastrophe beyond all proportions in the wake of Fukushima through the continued widespread use of nuclear energy.
The world was warned of the dangers of nuclear accidents 25 years ago, when Chernobyl exploded and lofted radioactive poisons into the atmosphere. Those poisons “rained out”, creating hot spots over the northern hemisphere. Research by scientists in eastern Europe, collected and published by the New York Academy of Sciences, estimates that 40 per cent of the European landmass is now contaminated with caesium-137 and other radioactive poisons that will concentrate in food for hundreds to thousands of years.
Wide areas of Asia—from Turkey to China—the United Arab Emirates, north Africa and north America are also contaminated. Nearly 200 million people remain exposed.
That research estimated that by now close to a million people have died of causes linked to the Chernobyl disaster. They perished from cancers, congenital deformities, immune deficiencies, infections, cardiovascular diseases, endocrine abnormalities and radiation-induced factors that increased infant mortality. Studies in Belarus found that in 2000, 14 years after the Chernobyl disaster, fewer than 20 per cent of the children were considered “practically healthy”, compared to 90 per cent before Chernobyl.
Now, Fukushima has been called the second-worst nuclear disaster after Chernobyl. Much is still uncertain about the long-term consequences of this disaster. Fukushima may well be on par with or even far exceed Chernobyl in terms of the effects on public health, as new information becomes available. The crisis is ongoing; the plant remains unstable and radiation emissions continue into the air and water.
Recent monitoring by citizens’ groups, international organisations and the US government have found dangerous hotspots in Tokyo and other areas. The Japanese government, meanwhile, in late September lifted evacuation advisories for some areas near the damaged plant—even though high levels of radiation remained. The government estimated that it will spend at least $13 billion to clean up contamination.
Illustration by Leandro Lima
Many thousands of people continue to inhabit areas that are highly contaminated, particularly northwest of Fukushima. Radioactive elements have been deposited throughout northern Japan, found in tap water in Tokyo and concentrated in tea, beef, rice and other food. In one of the few studies on human contamination in the months following the accident, over half the more than 1,000 children whose thyroids were monitored in Fukushima city were found to be contaminated with iodine-131—this means many of them are condemned to thyroid cancer years from now. Children are innately sensitive to the carcinogenic effects of radiation, foetuses even more so.Like the Chernobyl meltdown, the accident at Fukushima, too, is of global proportions.
|
Fukushima is classified as a Grade-7 accident on the International Atomic Energy Agency scale, denoting “widespread health and environmental effects”. That is the same severity as Chernobyl, the only other Grade-7 accident in history, but such disaster measurement is hazy: there is no higher number on the agency’s scale.
After the accident, lobbying groups touted improved safety at nuclear installations globally. In Japan, the Tokyo Electric Power Co, which operates the Fukushima Daiichi reactors, and the government have sought to control the reporting of negative stories via telecom companies and internet service providers.
In Britain, The Guardian reported that days after the tsunami, companies with interests in nuclear power—Areva, EDF Energy and Westinghouse—worked with the government to downplay the accident, fearing setbacks on plans for new nuclear power plants.
Nuclear power has always been the nefarious Trojan horse for the weapons industry, and effective publicity campaigns are a hallmark of both industries. The concept of nuclear electricity was conceived in the early 1950s as a way to make the public more comfortable with the US development of nuclear weapons. “The atomic bomb will be accepted far more readily if at the same time atomic energy is being used for constructive ends,” a consultant to the Defense Department Psychological Strategy Board, Stefan Possony, suggested.
The phrase ‘Atoms for Peace’ was popularised by President Dwight Eisenhower in the early 1950s.
Nuclear power and nuclear weapons are one and the same technology. A 1,000-MW nuclear reactor generates 600 pounds or so of plutonium per year: an atomic bomb requires a fraction of that amount for fuel, and plutonium remains radioactive for 2,50,000 years. Therefore, every country with a nuclear power plant also has a bomb factory with unlimited potential.
The nuclear power industry sets an unforgivable precedent by exporting nuclear technology—bomb factories—to dozens of non-nuclear nations.
Why is nuclear power still viable, after we’ve witnessed catastrophic accidents, enormous financial outlays, weapons proliferation and nuclear-waste-induced epidemics of cancers and genetic disease for generations to come? Simply put, many government and other officials believe the nuclear industry mantra: safe, clean and green. And the public is not educated on the issue.
There are some signs of change. Germany will phase out nuclear power by 2022. Italy and Switzerland have decided against it, and anti-nuclear advocates in Japan have gained traction. China remains cautious on nuclear power. Yet the nuclear enthusiasm of the United States, Britain, Russia and Canada continues unabated. The industry, meanwhile, has promoted new modular and ‘advanced’ reactors as better alternatives to traditional reactors. They are, however, subject to the very same risks—accidents, terrorist attacks, human error—as the traditional reactors. Many also create fissile material for bombs as well as the legacy of radioactive waste.
True green, clean, nearly emission-free solutions exist for providing energy. They lie in a combination of conservation and renewable energy sources—mainly wind, solar and geothermal, hydropower plants and biomass from algae. A smart-grid could make possible the integration of consuming and producing devices, allowing flexible operation of household appliances. The problem of intermittent power can be solved by storing energy using available technologies.
Millions of jobs can be created by replacing nuclear power with nationally integrated, renewable energy systems. In the United States alone, this project could be paid for by the $180 billion currently allocated for nuclear weapons programmes over the next decade. In fact, there would be no need for new weapons if the Russian and American nuclear arsenals—95 per cent of the estimated 20,500 nuclear weapons globally—are abolished.
Advocates of nuclear energy often paint those who oppose them as Luddites who are afraid of, or do not understand, modern technology, or as hysterics who disproportionately exaggerate the dangers of nuclear power. One might recall the sustained attack over many decades by the tobacco industry upon the medical profession—a profession that revealed the grave health dangers induced by smoking. Smoking, broadly speaking, only kills the smoker, active or passive. Nuclear power bequeaths morbidity and mortality—epidemics of disease—to all future generations. The millions of lives lost to smoking in the era before the health risks of cigarettes were widely exposed will be minuscule compared to the medical catastrophe we face through the continued use of nuclear power.
Let’s use this extraordinary moment to convince governments and others to move toward a nuclear-free world. Let’s prove that informed democracies will behave in a responsible fashion.
-Dr. Helen Caldicott
(Helen Caldicott, Paediatrician, founder-president, Physicians for Social Responsibility, anti-nuclear activist)
Courtesy: Outlook Magazine, Jan 02, 2012
16 December 2011
Deploying Renewable Energy To Protect Us From Nuclear Accidents
The proponents of nuclear power have been saying that it is cheap, green and can be a major part of the future energy policy. Though such arguments have chosen to be silent on the huge consequences of a nuclear accident, they seem to imply that the costs to our communities from the horrors of nuclear power policy should be acceptable in comparison to the benefits from it. Is nuclear power really cheap, safe and green? Is there no alternative but to consider it as the major part of the future energy policy? In view of the huge opposition going on in the country w.r.t the Koodankulam nuclear power plant, and all the proposed nuclear power parks in the country, a rational look at much benign alternatives to nuclear power has become urgent.
The IPCC report ‘Special Report Renewable Energy Sources (SRREN)', which was released in May 2011, has projected a very critical role for renewable energy sources, and hence deserves greater attention for enabling a paradigm shift in our energy policy to eliminate the chances of Nuclear Accidents.
Even though many individuals and reports have been advocating, for decades, a strong push for an energy policy for the country based on renewable energy sources, not only to contain the GHG emissions but also for the need to adopt a sustainable energy policy for the all-round development of our growing population, the successive governments have continued the reliance on conventional energy sources, such as coal based, dam based and nuclear based power, for political reasons. The result of such over reliance on conventional energy sources has been of disastrous consequences to our society: about 40% of the population still has no electricity connection, the exploitation of natural resources including forests and rivers have reached unsustainable levels, and the pollution of air, water and land have reached dangerous proportion. The horrors of nuclear accidents, as experienced at Chernobyl and Fukushima , will be in addition to these problems. The question our society should be addressing is whether the credible risks from nuclear power are avoidable?
Whereas many international communities have unambiguously acknowledged the urgent need to contain the GHG emissions through reduced reliance on conventional energy sources, and whereas the govt. of India itself took a lot of pride in announcing a National Action Plan on Climate Change (NAPCC) for this purpose, the approval being accorded for a huge number of coal based, dam based and nuclear based power projects all over the country in recent years have clearly indicated the large gap between what the govt. claims to do and what it actually does.
It is sincerely hoped that the recent IPCC report ‘Special Report Renewable Energy Sources (SRREN)' which has projected that the renewable energy could account for almost 80% of the world's energy supply within four decades, will galvanise the half hearted efforts of the govt. to become concerted efforts to move towards a paradigm shift. But it should be noted that the IPCC report has clearly said that the projection that the r enewable energy could account for almost 80% of the world's energy supply within four decades is feasible only if governments pursue the policies needed to promote green power. The report has said that if the full range of renewable technologies were deployed, the world could keep greenhouse gas concentrations to less than 450 parts per million, the level scientists have predicted will be the limit of safety beyond which climate change becomes catastrophic and irreversible.
A very crucial point in this regard is that investing in renewable energy to the desired extent (80% of world's energy supply within four decades) would cost only about 1% of global GDP annually, as against huge cost of about 25% of global GDP estimated to mitigate the impacts of Global Warming.
Ramon Pichs, co-chair of one of the key IPCC working groups, has said: "The report shows that it is not the availability of [renewable] resources but the public policies that will either expand or constrain renewable energy development over the coming decades. Developing countries have an important stake in the future – this is where most of the 1.4 billion people without access to electricity live yet also where some of the best conditions exist for renewable energy deployment." Sven Teske, renewable energy director at Greenpeace International, and a lead author of the report, has said: "The IPCC report shows overwhelming scientific evidence that renewable energy can also meet the growing demand of developing countries, where over 2 billion people lack access to basic energy services and can do so at a more cost-competitive and faster rate than conventional energy sources. Governments have to kick start the energy revolution by implementing renewable energy laws across the globe."
An earlier report by Greenpeace ‘Energy [R]evolution: A sustainable Energy Outlook for India ', had referred to this scenario. It had said: renewable energy, combined with efficiencies from the ‘smart use' of energy, can deliver half of India 's primary energy needs by 2050, according to the report. Some of the highlights of the summary for the policy makers in IPCC report are worth mentioning in this context:
• Recent data confirm that the consumption of fossil fuels accounts for the majority of global anthropogenic GHG emissions.• As well as having a large potential to mitigate climate change, renewable energy (RE) can provide wider benefits.• In various settings RE are already economically competitive.• The cost of most RE technologies has declined and additional expected technical advances would result in further cost reduction.• Various RE resources are already being successfully integrated into energy supply systems and into end –use sectors.• There are multiple pathways for increasing the share of RE across all end-use sectors.• RE can contribute to social and economic development; can accelerate access to energy, particularly to the people without access to electricity; RE options can contribute to a more secure energy supply.• In addition to reduced GHG emissions, RE technologies can provide other important environmental benefits.
The scientists have also predicted in this report that the RE will play a greater role than either nuclear or carbon capture and storage in reducing the GHG emissions by 2050. The calamitous path of the present govt. to increase the nuclear power capacity from 4,800 MW to 275,000 MW by 2050; the projection by Integrated Energy Policy (IEP) that coal power capacity should increase from 80,000 MW to 400,000 MW and the hydel capacity to grow from 37,000 MW to 150,000 MW by 2031-32 should be objectively questioned in this context.
Through a recent referendum Germany has decided to close down all its nuclear power plants by 2022. Japan also is known to be reviewing its nuclear policy. It must be noted that both Germany and Japan have more than 20% of their power generation capacity from nuclear power plants. Both countries are large importers of fossil fuels. Despite these constraints they are reviewing their policy of nuclear reliance. Many other countries are trying to come out of the shackles of their respective nuclear lobbies to review their own energy strategies. But it is rather shocking that India is still dithering on responding effectively to the global rethink on nuclear power.
The social, economic and environmental issues associated with nuclear power should be of great concern to our communities. Hence there is an urgent need for the country to adopt a paradigm shift in the way we look at the demand and supply of energy, and accept the reality that only the renewable energy sources can provide sustainable development for our communities.
Since India is still in the developmental stage, and since its many communities have not committed to huge reliance on commercial energy sources, it is in a very good position to move away from the calamitous path of over reliance on conventional energy sources without having to experience great socio-economic upheavals. India 's tropical location provides huge potential in RE sources. Even if a small percentage of the money that is planned to be spent on conventional power sources in next 20 years is invested wisely in encouraging the widespread usage of RE, the country's move to low carbon energy pathway will be quicker, cheaper and smoother. This will be in the overall interest of the society too.
A quick appreciation of the huge solar energy potential provides a stark figure. Assuming about 30 crore house holds in the country by 2031-32 (@ 4 persons per house), and assuming that about 7.5 crore houses (25% of the total) in the country will be suitable and economically able to install roof-top solar photo voltaic systems of 2 kW each, about 150,000 MW installed capacity of solar power in distributed mode is feasible at low additional cost to the society. If we also exploit a small percentage of the roof top surfaces available at schools, colleges, industries, offices, commercial and sports establishments etc. the potential available through solar energy alone is gigantic. The real cost to society of this investment will be very small as compared to that of nuclear power.
According to the World Institute of Sustainable Energy (WISE), the grid connected renewable energy potential of the country is very high. Its estimates are:
• Wind Energy – 100,000 MW;• CSP based solar power generation – 200,000 MW;• Solar PV based power generation – 200,000 MW ( here available space may not be a problem, if we also consider all the rooftops available ).
Whereas as per IEP projection the demand for electricity generation by 2031-32 is about 3,600 Billion kWH/year, solar energy potential in the country is estimated to be about 5,000 trillion kWH/year. The true potential of various modes of solar power is so great that even if we can harness about 0.1% of it, all the energy needs of the country can be met.
IEP has basically looked at the grid interactive potential of renewable energy sources. These sources, especially solar energy has very huge potential, if distributed type potential such as small size roof top or community based renewable energy plants are considered. The same is true with all other renewable energy sources. Because of the huge losses involved in Transmission and Distribution of generated electricity, all the attendant problems such as theft, organizational issues, huge capital expenditure to the state, technical problems such as voltage stability etc., which are salient features of a grid interactive energy sources, distributed renewable energy sources are best suited for rural electrification and for small loads such as lighting, other domestic appliances, small pumping needs etc. The potential of the new & renewable energy sources can almost be termed as unlimited when they are effectively used as distributed energy sources.
The distributed renewable energy sources have the following advantages as compared to the present grid based system of large conventional power plants:
• Will greatly reduce the effective demand on the grid based power supply system; will drastically reduce the T&D losses; and vastly improve the power supply to those consumers essentially needing the grid supply; much better voltage profile; leads to much reduced spending on grid management;• Will drastically reduce the need for fossil fuel based, dam based and nuclear power stations and the associated transmission & distribution network; reduced complexity in system operation;• Will assist in drastically reducing the GHG emissions and other pollutants;• Will provide a sustainable, environmental and people friendly energy supply model;• Will accelerate the rural electrification due to shorter gestation period of individual projects;• Will lead to increase in rural employment opportunities, and hence assists in minimizing urban migration;• Will require negligible or nil additional resources such as land and water;• Their impact on the environment will be minimal, and they are inexhaustible;• Lead to much reduced growth in demand (CAGR) for grid electricity;• Avoided costs of recurring fuel expenditure and of peak load power stations;• Absence of the need for people's displacement.
Two most common questions raised in case of new and renewable energy sources are that they are not firm power and that their comparable cost with conventional energy sources is high. The reality behind these issues is as follows:
• Many applications like lighting loads, water pumping for domestic and smaller agricultural needs, water heating for bathing etc. are not heavy and do not require 24 hours supply. Lighting loads can be adequately met by backup battery systems when the main sources like solar or wind energy is not available. These battery systems can be charged by the respective energy sources. Applications like solar water heating with adequate capacity water storage facility need no battery backups. Solar water pumps for lighter agricultural or domestic loads are ideal for usage during the sunlight hours. These can also function much more reliably in conjunction with other renewable energy source of bio-mass and wind turbines where feasible. These sources are already in use in the country.
• Though it is true that the initial cost of these new and renewable energy sources seem to be high as compared to the conventional energy sources, it is only because the society has already invested very heavily for the infrastructure required for the development of the latter. Also, the real cost of recurring fuel needs in case of coal, diesel, natural gas or nuclear fuel will be avoided in the case of renewable energy sources. Whereas both the capital cost and energy cost from the conventional energy sources is increasing all the time, the same is opposite in case of new and renewable energy sources. Already the cost of new and renewable energy sources has come down by many times in the last decade. In addition, if we take the environmental costs, social costs, health costs, Global Warming mitigation costs, T&D losses and the large infrastructure required for the grid quality conventional energy sources, the distributed energy generation based on new and renewable energy sources will be much cheaper.
Ever growing competitiveness of solar power has become evident as per a recent report on India 's solar power programme of adding 20,000 MW by Year 2020 through which the government has proposed to buy solar power at 15,390 rupees a megawatt-hour. The lowest bid in a recent national solar auction (December 2011) came from Solairedirect SA, France 's second-largest producer, who is reported to have offered to sell photovoltaic-based electricity at 7,490 rupees a megawatt-hour. That's less than half the rate the government proposed, and 38 percent below the average price set in a previous round in December 2010. As per the industry observers, the solar power may equal the cost of fossil fuel-based electricity sold to commercial businesses as early as 2014 or 2015 if prices continue to fall at the rate seen in India in recent months.
In this context it is sad to observe that the total budgetary spending on new & renewable energy sources by the union govt. has been a small fraction of that spent on nuclear power. An objective analysis of all the societal costs and real benefits over the duration of the known life cycle of nuclear power as compared to that of new and renewable energy sources will reveal that the renewable energy sources are of much higher benefits to our society in from all considerations.
In this regard it is perplexing as to why the government is insisting to build many nuclear power plants such as Koodankulam at huge costs & risks to the society, when the much benign, less costly and more suitable renewable energy sources are waiting to be harnessed. With the recent IPCC report being so unambiguous on the potential of renewable energy sources, the Union govt. has no excuse anymore to continue to ignore the crucial role of renewable energy in our developmental path. India could be a leader in harnessing renewable energy since our life style is congenial for low per capita energy consumption, and since our country has a huge potential.
-Shankar Sharma
(Author is a Power Policy Analyst shankar.sharma2005@gmail.co)
Courtesy: http://www.countercurrents.org
22 November 2011
Some FAQs about Koodankulam and Nuclear Power: Nityanand Jayaraman and G. Sundar Rajan
Steel drums with nuclear waste. The inescapable byproduct generated from the fission of nuclear fuel in the form of uranium or plutonium creates what is called nuclear waste. This waste comes in a huge variety of extremely radioactive material with half-lives ranging from 8 days to hundreds of thousands of years. In other words their radioactivity takes a really, really long time to decay, thousands of times our human life-times. These fission products if released to the environment will last a long time, and it is almost impossible to decontaminate them.
NITYANAND JAYARAMAN and G. SUNDAR RAJAN of the Chennai Solidarity Group for Koodankulam Struggle developed the fact-sheet below in response to real questions that they encountered during the course of street and college campaigns. They say: “The questions were sincere, so we felt a sincere response was warranted.”
Introduction
Since August 2011, Tamilnadu has witnessed renewed protests against the commissioning of the first of two 1000 MW power plants as part of the Koodankulam Nuclear Power Project (KKNPP). While protests have been ongoing against the project since the proposal was mooted in 1988, the impending commissioning of the reactors in light of the devastating and uncontrollable nuclear meltdown in Fukushima, Japan, has rightly triggered a wave of concern among thinking people in India.
The protests against nuclear power plants is not isolated to Koodankulam. Even as we speak, fisherfolk and farmers in Jaitapur, Maharashtra and farmers and residents of Gorakhpur, Haryana, are saying a loud “No” to nuclear power plants in their area. Haripur, West Bengal, which was to be a site of Russian reactors, will no longer be on the nuclear map, as the State Government bowed to local sentiments and declared West Bengal a nuclear-free State.
Wise people do learn from others’ mistakes. Germany, Switzerland, Italy, Belgium and Japan have all announced that they will move away from the nuclear option, and explore clean and sustainable forms of electricity generation. But India’s chest-thumping “nucleocracy” wants to play the death game with peasants and fisherfolk as the pawns in the gamble.
The staunch and united protests by Farmers, Traders and fisher folks of Tirunelveli, Kanyakumari and Thoothukudi has scared the nuclear establishment. Faced with the real prospect of having to abandon the project, the Congress-led UPA Government is doing what it does best — Divide and Rule; communalise the issue, and allege that foreign hands are at play. At different times, the nuclear establishment and Dr. Manmohan Singh have said different things – that Tamilnadu’s industrialisation will falter without the project; that India cannot do without nuclear energy; that our nuclear plants are 100 percent safe; that abandoning the project at this stage can prove to be dangerous. When it comes to explaining the consequences of a major disaster, Indian scientists, including Dr. Kalam, have behaved more like astrologers than rationalists. How can anyone predict that no major earthquake will hit this area or that this human-made technology cannot fail?
The fears of Fukushima and the fears about continued electricity shortage have raised a number of conflicting emotions and doubts in people’s minds. This booklet aims to quell some of the misconceptions about the safety of nuclear energy, and answer some frequently arising questions.
1. India is a developing country. We need electricity to develop. If we rule out the nuclear option, won’t our development will be hampered?
Nuclear power is not the only option for generating electricity. There are a number of conventional and non-conventional sources of energy that can be explored for generating electricity. It is a fact that in more than 60 years of post-independence industrialisation and modernisation, the contribution of nuclear energy to the total electricity generation is less than 3 percent. Renewable energy sources already contribute more than 10 percent of India’s electricity and Large Hydro projects deliver about 22 percent. Large dams, though, have exacted a devastating toll on the environment and lives of adivasi communities.
For India to emerge as a true leader, we have to be careful not to destroy our natural capital – our waters, lands, air and people. By saying “No” to dangerous, risky and expensive technologies like nuclear, we create opportunities to develop cleaner, saner and less dangerous forms of electricity generation.
Increasing the available electricity can also be achieved by conservation and demand-side management strategies. For every 100 MW of electricity generated in India, more than 40 MW is lost because of inefficient transmission and distribution (T&D). Industrialised countries like Sweden have a T&D loss of less than 7 percent. In other words, of the total 180,000 megawatts of electricity generated in India, 72,000 megawatts (40 percent) is lost, wasted. That is equivalent to shutting off all power plants in the States of Maharashtra, Gujarat, Tamilnadu, Andhra Pradesh, and Karnataka.
If efficiency were to be increased to, say 90 percent, the savings would be the equivalent of setting up a 60,000 MW power plant – or about 60 plants the size of the Koodankulam plant that is currently at the heart of a controversy – with a fraction of the investment and none of the risks. Increasing energy efficiency of electrical appliances is another way to save electricity. In Tamilnadu alone, if incandescent lamps are converted to LED bulbs, we can save about 2,000MW.
Add to all this, the benefits of cutting on wasteful consumption. Shopping malls and IT companies burn electricity throughout the day. Night or day, lights and AC are running, even while households and small commercial establishments have to suffer power outages. There must be a rationalisation of the use of electricity. The fact that villages surrounding Kalpakkam where a nuclear plant is situated are reeling under major power shortages is itself proof of “inequitable distribution” of electricity.
2. Is renewable energy technologically viable? Will it be able to meet our energy needs?
Meeting India’s energy needs requires more than just renewable energy, especially since electricity is merely one form of energy. In India, electricity meets only 12 percent of total energy needs. People make do without electric lighting or cooling. But even the most indigent family needs fuel for cooking. Biomass (firewood or cow dung patties) is by far the most important source of energy for the nation.
India’s energy security depends on the robustness of our paradigm of harnessing and deploying energy in various forms, and in forms meaningful to the millions of under-served Indians. The current paradigm promotes inefficient energy generation and transmission, inequitable distribution and consumption wherein rural areas and small commercial establishments suffer even while elite users enjoy uninterrupted access to electricity and other forms of energy. With the current wasteful and unjust modes of production and consumption, neither conventional nor renewable forms of electricity generation will suffice. Why is that villages that are reeling under the effects of pollution from the thermal plants in Singrauli, UP – once hailed as the energy capital of India – have neither electricity nor clean water? While challenging coal and nuclear, we also need to question a development model that incessantly calls for sacrifices by adivasis, dalits, farmers and fisherfolk so that others may prosper.
On the topic of renewable forms of energy for electricity generation, though, the fact remains that we have barely scratched the surface in terms of harnessing the potential. According to the Government of India, India’s potential in renewables is as follows: wind energy – 48,500 MW (65,000MW, according to Indian Wind Energy Association http://www.inwea.org/); small hydro power – 15,000 MW; biomass Energy – 21,000 MW; and at least 4,00,000 MW from Solar Energy. The monumental amounts of money being sunk into nuclear technology can be gainfully diverted to increase research in renewables, and electrical energy efficiency. Already, advances in solar and wind technologies are reducing per MW costs. The capacity of existing wind mills can be increased six to eight-fold by replacing older, lower-capacity turbines, with newer, higher capacity turbines, or by installing new and more efficient turbines amidst existing wind mills. In the last 15 years, India has added about 17,000MW of power using renewable sources; China has added the same amount in just one year. So, where is the need to put all our eggs in just the “Nuclear Basket”?
Secondly, many of the applications of electricity can be met by smart design. Tinted glass buildings in a city like Chennai require the burning of electricity for lighting throughout the day, even when the sun is shining brightly outside. Our city’s malls and the IT companies in the Knowledge Corridor are examples of such “stupid” design.
In Germany’s Black Forest region, an ordinary woman named Ursula Sladek, mobilised people to pay for the take over of the electricity company after the Chernobyl disaster. Today, the people-owned company supplies electricity generated from small, decentralised renewable sources to more than 100,000 customers. After the Fukushima disaster, an average of 400 new customers are subscribing to the company requesting clean electricity. It is clear that electricity from renewable energy is not just environmentally sustainable but also commercially viable.
3. Can we, as Dr. Abdul Kalam says, let one disaster (in Fukushima) derail our dreams of becoming an economically developed nation?
Besides the better known disasters at Kyshtym, in erstwhile USSR (1957), Three Mile Island (1979) and Chernobyl (1986), at least 76 nuclear accidents totalling $19.1 billion in damages have occurred between 1947 and 2008. Most of these accidents – 56 to be precise – happened after the Chernobyl disaster. This translates to one serious nuclear incident every year causing $332 million in damages annually. Between 2005 and 2055, at least four serious nuclear accidents are likely to occur, according to calculations by an interdisciplinary study titled “The Future of Nuclear Power” conducted by Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 2003. The 2011 Fukushima disaster is the first of MIT’s prophetic estimates.
And it is not just disasters that we are concerned about. Even nuclear reactors that “operate perfectly” are associated with higher risks of cancer and unexplained deaths. In the US, where 104 reactors are operating at 65 sites, elevated rates of leukemia and brain cancers are reported from communities near nuclear power plants.
Studies conducted by Dr. V. Pugazhenthi, a physician and researcher, who provides medical service in the nuclear town of Kalpakkam, Tamilnadu, have revealed elevated incidences of congenital deformities like polydactyly (webbed fingers), thyroid problems and various kinds of cancers among the residents living around the nuclear facility.
4. Dr. Abdul Kalam says coal-fired power plants are dirty because they cause pollution and emit tons and tons of climate-changing carbon. He points out to the devastating impacts of coal mining on the environment and the lives of communities in the vicinity.
Dr. Kalam is right about coal-fired power plants. Coal plants are dirty and polluting. Coal mines are hells on earth. But we should not be forced to choose between two evils – nuclear or coal. Would you like to be tortured or killed? My answer is “Neither.”
Dr. Kalam does not talk of the effects of uranium mining on the environment and health of communities. In Jadugoda, Jharkhand, where India’s uranium is mined by the Uranium Corporation of India Ltd, the effects of radiation among the local adivasi population are horrendous. Indian Doctors for Peace and Development, a national chapter of the Nobel-winning International Physicians for Prevention of Nuclear War, recently published a health study on Jadugoda. The study found that:
• Primary sterility is more common in the people residing near uranium mining operations.
• More children with congenital deformities are being born to mothers living near uranium mining operations.
• Congenital defects as a cause of death of children are higher among mothers living near uranium mines.
• Cancer as a cause of death is more common in villages surrounding uranium operations.
• Life expectancy of people living near uranium mining operations is lower than Jharkhand’s state average and lower than in villages far removed from the mines.
• All these indicators of poor health and increased vulnerability is despite the fact that the affected villages have better economic and literacy status than reference villages.
The path to a sustainable and socially just future lies in moving away from environmentally destructive technologies such as coal and nuclear. Nuclear energy will not help us combat climate change. Per unit of power, nuclear energy emits four to five times more Carbon dioxide (CO2) than renewable energy. If the entire nuclear fuel cycle is considered, the emissions are even higher.
5. Why are people protesting only now? Couldn’t they have told the Government that they don’t want the project when it was first proposed?
The project was first proposed in 1988. Within months, protests built up against the nuclear plant. People and students mobilised 1 million signatures against the nuclear plant to hand over to Mikhail Gorbachev, the then Premier of USSR, when he visited India in 1989. Black flag protests, youth mobilisation, rallies in Chennai and other urban centres. Koodankulam has been a controversial issue from Day One. On May 1, 1989, fisherfolk and other residents from around the project site organised a massive rally in Kanyakumari town. The peaceful rally was disrupted by the police, and one youngster – Ignatius – was shot in the police firing that ensued. Between 1991 and 2001, the protests died down, because USSR – the technology provider – splintered into several smaller nations. But this history is glossed over by the propagandists, and repeated without verification by a lazy and irresponsible media.
Like the Rajiv Gandhi Government at that time, the Sonia Gandhi Government now has refused to acknowledge the protests or heed the aspirations of local people.
That is evident from the manner in which the Central Government is hell-bent on pushing the Jaitapur nuclear project in the face of stiff opposition by local farmers and fisherfolk. Protests in Gorakhpur, Haryana, and Jaitapur are not just being ignored, but violently repressed.
It is true that the imminent commissioning of the Koodankulam plant, and the threat of expansion of the complex to accommodate 6,000 MW of capacity has re-awakened the fears of the local people. The 2004 tsunami gave the coastal people first hand experience of the raw fury of nature. The television images of the devastation caused by the triple disaster in Fukushima, and the subsequent tragedy of lakhs of Japanese were prevented from returning to their homes or to their normal lives are still fresh in the minds of people. People would be stupid to not be fearful.
6. Crores of rupees have already been spent on constructing the plant. Isn’t it too late to abandon the project now?
It is never too late to do the right thing. It is better to write off a bad investment, than to continue investing in spite of knowing the certainty of routine nuclear pollution and the risks of a disaster.
Consider the costs of a disaster. Belarus, a state in the erstwhile USSR, suffered the maximum damage as a result of the 1986 Chernobyl nuclear disaster. According to a report by the International Atomic Energy Agency, between 1991 and 2003, Belarus spent $13 billion on disaster-related expenses. It has estimated its losses over 30 years at $235 billion. In Ukraine, the country where Chernobyl was located, still allocates 6-7 percent of total Government spending on disaster rehabilitation programs. Radiation fallout from the disaster has contaminated more than 200,000 square kilometers, mostly in Russia, Belarus and Ukraine. That is about twice the size of Tamilnadu.
In Fukushima, just closing down and safely dismantling the Dai-Ichi nuclear plant will take 30 years and cost between $12 billion and $19 billion. This does not include the costs of health monitoring, evacuation and social security, remediation of contaminated environment, the economic losses arising from loss of agriculture and fisheries income, or the foreign trade lost due fear of radiation contamination.
If a decision to opt out of nuclear power is taken, there is still time to convert the Koodankulam plant to a less risky and less polluting technology such as a gas thermal plant. The Shoreham nuclear plant in Long Island, New York, was converted to work on natural gas after the Three Mile Island accident took place. The William H Zimmer nuclear plant in Ohio, and the Midland Cogeneration Facility in Michigan were similarly converted to run on fossil fuel.
7. Indian nuclear plants are safe. So many of India’s nuclear plants have run for decades without mishaps. So what’s the problem?
The claim that Indian nuclear plants are safe is contrary to facts. Safety breaches in India’s nuclear establishment seldom comes to light because of the shroud of secrecy surrounding the institutions. But what little we know gives serious cause for concern. Just take the case of Kalpakkam. The following violations have come to light, including some that were acknowledged more than 6 months after the incident.
• 1987: A refuelling accident ruptured the reactor core.
• 1991: Workers were exposed to radioactive heavy water
• 1999: 42 workers were exposed to radiation
• 2002: 100 kg of radioactive sodium was released into the environment
• 2003: 6 workers were exposed to high levels of radiation
Other very serious incidents have happened in other reactors. In 1991, a contractor working in the RAPS reactor complex used radioactive heavy water to mix paint, and wash the brush, face and hands.
In November 2009, more than 55 workers in Kaiga nuclear plant, Karnataka, were exposed to excessive levels of radiation when they drank water laced with radioactive tritium.
Addition of safety systems have often been an afterthought. A November 1986 report titled “Safety of the Indian Pressurised Heavy Water Reactors” by the Department of Atomic Energy’s Reactor Safety Analysis Group states that “In India, tsunamis and seiches do not occur. Hence cyclones alone have been singled out for detailed study.” This analysis was for Pressurised Heavy Water Reactors (PHWR) of the kind that is installed in Kalpakkam. The 2004 tsunami flooded the entire township and reactor complex. The Kalpakkam reactor survived the 2004 tsunami not by design but by chance.
Even today, the Kalpakkam reactor is not designed to survive a major earthquake or tsunami despite the fact that an International Atomic Energy Agency publication of 2011 identifies one active submarine volcano near the coast of India, and that is off the coast of Pondicherry, 60 km from Kalpakkam.
8. All safety systems are in place in Koodankulam. Dr. Kalam says the plant is 100 percent safe, and that there is no threat of a tsunami since the plant is located 1300 km from the seismic centre point. He has urged people to have faith in the Government, and to believe Governmental experts and engineers. Shouldn’t people do that instead of questioning the experts?
First, any good scientist or engineer will tell you that there is no such thing as 100 percent safe. Such a declaration is 100 percent false. Rather than educating people on the true nature of the risks, and the magnitude of effects in the event of a disaster, Dr. Kalam seems intent on lulling them into complacence. Complacence is the worst thing that can happen for disaster preparedness. It is outright irresponsible to lie to people about the true nature of dangerous technologies.
Second, despite the 2004 tsunami, which belied the Department of Atomic Energy’s declaration that “In India, tsunamis. . .do not occur,” we have Dr. Kalam repeating this false statement. Dr. Kalam’s statement that a tsunami will not occur belongs in the realm of astrology and not science.
Dr. Kalam would have us believe that safety and emergency response are merely matters of technology. That is not true. Robust safety and emergency response systems have to do with siting, planning, the setting up and maintenance of escape routes, an informed citizenry that is trained to react appropriately, an open and transparent administration that is capable of acknowledging and correcting mistakes, engineers and technologists that respect nature’s power, and builders and contractors that are honest.
Good science and technology requires an unwavering commitment to truth, a trait that is in short supply in this country. With scams tainting every aspect of Indian life, people who heed Dr. Kalam’s advice to trust the Government and its engineers would be acting unwisely.
In 2010, a pedestrian bridge constructed for the much-hyped Commonwealth Games collapsed a week before the launch of the Games. The use of sub-standard material and poor construction methods are not restricted to relatively lower risk structures like the ill-fated pedestrian bridge.
In May 1994, the inner containment dome of a nuclear reactor under construction in Kaiga, Karnataka, collapsed sending 120 tonnes of concrete crashing down. The dome is meant to contain radiation in the event of an accident. A. Gopalakrishnan, Atomic Energy Regulatory Board’s former head, writes that “Senior NPC civil engineers and the private firms which provide civil engineering designs. . .to the DAE have had a close relationship. In this atmosphere of comradeship, the NPC engineers did not carry out the necessary quality checks on the designs they received.” If the dome had collapsed when the plant was in operation, we would have had a Level 7 meltdown on our hands.
In July 2011, even as the disastrous events in Fukushima were unfolding, the Leningrad-2 nuclear reactor under construction in Russia experienced a serious mishap. Shortly after concrete was poured for the construction of the outer protective shell of a reactor unit, the structure began to deform, with the reinforcement bars bending and dangling about 26 feet above ground. The reactor under construction is of the VVER 1200 type, a generation ahead of the VVER 1000 reactors currently installed in Koodankulam. Experts have speculated that corruption and use of substandard material may have been behind the mishap. In Koodankulam, we are witnessing the setting up of a high-risk technology by two nations – India and Russia – which compete with each other in the realm of corruption.
9. Aren’t you being anti-science and emotional in protesting against nuclear power?
The argument against Koodankulam is not an argument against science and experimentation. 10,000 MW as in Jaitapur and Koodankulam are not experiments. These are not 100 kilowatt reactions in a lab condition. They are massive investments in power generation technology putting more than just the lives of experimenters at risk. Unwilling people cannot be asked to sacrifice their lives in the interest of Kalam’s science. It is true that many experimenters have sacrificed their lives at the altar of science, and we need to acknowledge them with gratitude. The Nazis experimenting with poisonous chemicals on unsuspecting and unwilling captive Jews, or the pharmaceutical companies currently testing their dangerous medicines on indigent and choiceless people may be contributing to the advancement of science. But their methods are plain criminal. The people supporting the Koodankulam struggle are not “Can’t Doers;” They are “Won’t Doers.” Dr. Kalam is not talking about risking his life for the advancement of science; he is blaming the Koodankulam people for refusing to risk their lives.
Good engineers and scientists require humility, integrity and an ability to accept mistakes and move ahead with the learnings. India’s nucleocracy lacks all these.
It is not the villagers that need convincing. Insurance companies are not convinced that nuclear plants are risk free. On the contrary, they believe that the risks of a nuclear blow-out are uninsurable. If the Koodankulam plant is completely safe as Dr. Kalam puts it, it would be useful to see Dr. Kalam convincing the insurance companies to provide blanket cover to nuclear power plants, and convincing the nuclear equipment suppliers to abandon their insistence on a nuclear liability protocol that exempts them from compensating in the event of a disaster, even if it is caused by a willful fault on their part.
Building a nuclear plant merely on the basis of a belief – as if in God – that a tsunami or major earthquake will not occur is what is anti-science. People who are agitated and fearful of the consequences of the nuclear technology being set up in India are scientific because their fears are based on the empirical evidence of regular disasters and a knowledge of the socio-economic and environmental fallouts of such disasters. The fear is further fuelled by the lack of transparency that shrouds nuclear establishments in India and elsewhere. Apprehension over the likelihood of a disaster given the numerous things that could go wrong technically or due to corruption or malpractices is not unscientific, especially given what is unfolding in terms of 2G scams.
What is being asked is for scientists and engineers to devote their skills in less destructive and risky means of generating electricity.
10. Every technology has its risks. Cars, ships and trains routinely have accidents. You don’t see us abandoning cars and ships. Then why should we abandon nuclear power?
Car accidents or even plane accidents do not leave behind a 20 km exclusion zone in which human life cannot return to normal for decades. A person driving in a car or travelling by plane accepts certain risks voluntarily. A car or a plane accident does not affect the next generation and the unborn. The unborn cannot even be consulted on whether the risk that we are taking is acceptable to them. Imposing such a risk on generations to come is patently unjust. Car accidents do not necessitate the evacuation of people living in a 75 km circle.
Until a technology’s risks are proven to be manageable – and we have seen the unmanageability of the nuclear technology on occasion after occasion – wisdom advises that it be kept in the realm of experimentation. It certainly cannot be unleashed on an unsuspecting community.
11. Dr. Kalam has offered a Rs. 200 crore development package including clean water, jobs, schools, hospitals and motor boats and cold storage facilities to the people in the villages surrounding Koodankulam. Will that not make this development more inclusive?
This offer of Rs. 200 crore is perverse. “If you can’t convince them, bribe them” seems to be the line taken by Dr. Kalam. How different is this from the spate of freebies offered by politicians before elections? Does this mean that if people don’t consent to the nuclear power plant, they will be denied hospitals, schools and clean water? What about other communities where no nuclear power plant is proposed to be built? Will they have to wait for one to be constructed in their backyard so that their rights to water and education can piggyback on that project?
The people are looking for answers to serious questions. Dr. Kalam should answer them respectfully, or restrain himself from speaking.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


